We changed a layover hotel in EVV due to a similar event. I know the F/O who was part of the crew involved.
I grew up in the PHF area and it was not the best back in the late 60s, early 70s. I've been back enough to see the changes and they aren't all good. PHF airport used to be worse than it is now. There's also a lot of military in the area, thus a lot of transient activity. Fort Eustis and Langley AFB are the nearest installations.
Is the hotel along U.S. 17? That was, and may still be, a high crime area.
Good luck and fly safe!