Drew said, "which is why I stopped routing for my company like a sports team a long time ago."
It's funny how we all do this, isn't it? I think we believe the hype. In 1998 at my IOE at AirTran a senior manager told us, "We hired you because you're the best of the best!"
... yeah right. They hired us because we were willing to show up.
The Comair guys have a sign outside their crewroom (trailer) door that says, "Through this door passes the world's finest airline pilots".
We all tend to buy the hype. We want to know that the decisions we made were the right ones. We want to believe that we had the wisdom to make the correct career decisions in a field where only a fraction are successful.
I'm just as guilty of "rooting for the home team". I buy company logo t-shirts, and company logo license plates (got a whole stack of those in my garage.)
Ultimately though, the success of our decisions are a matter of fate. We chart the course for our career and end up making deviations around buildups. More often then not we end up in sucker holes. A lucky few pop out into clear blue sky and have a nice smooth ride.
Anyway, i'm rambling. The point is that these guys never wanted to work for MidAtlantic. They are there because the former CEO promised a "soft landing" for furloughed pilots if the US Airways MEC would agree to (once again) lift the scope language and allow more and bigger airplanes to be flown off the property.
Now they face a furlough for the second time in 3 years and, for some of them, the 3rd time in a decade (from the same company!)
Was it their "choice" to hire on with a struggling airline? Were they victims of past mergers? Did they look at market conditions in 1999 and bet on a CEO with a stellar track record? Did they look at upgrade times at UAL and AMR vs. US Airways and bet on the promised growth?
Who knows. The point is, they never thought they'd be faced with this decision.
How many of you are senior Captains at Chautaua -- say those hired before 1998?
If Beford came up to you tomorrow and told you that he was spinning off the E145 fleet and that you would have to start over as first year F/Os at first year pay -- would you do it? Or would you look for a better opportunity.
Chautauqua is a fine airline. I dont think ANY of us in 1996 could have foreseen what it would become. Amazing. But, its fortunes could turn just as quickly. Try not to chastise the MDA pilots for not seeing your vision -- they've likely seen it before at airline after airline. Once you've been burned a few times you're much more cautious about the "opportunities" you're willing to subject your families to.