Take this for what it's worth... Yes HR has the majority of control when it comes to the applicants... They sift through the various stacks of resumes (yes, stacks... One stack for guys with a local address, another for a local with internal recs, another for non-local with internal recs and so on...). Then they start making calls for interviews... If you have made to stage two then they total up all your points and you are now in a list in the order of how you did on the testing, interviews and sim.... From there the list goes in front of the CPs and they start at the top of it and work down and pull names for the third phase... The list of names is good for the whole year from when they opened the application window... If you get the third phase call you are as good as in... Unless Farkas catches something really stupid that you put down ( it's happened and they were done... Take your time on the psych tests)... This break down is from what I have been told and from what I have witnessed myself after three years of bangingnmynhead on their door.... It's not perfect but there is not one company out there that doesn't make you jump through the hoops...
Lately it seems that they take a cross section of all types of flying backgrounds.... One class is not all 121 regional guys... Its a mix of international freight, local 135, local cargo, mainland regional, military, etc...
JMT... I was told that you have to see more than just the CP.... Maybe you have... If you can get upto the training dept with some of the HAL pilots you know then that will help.... Talk to the director of training, the director of ops, even the contract guys that are retired HAL pilots ( those guys have amazing influence... Just ask all the guys coming over from Trans Air).... If you have done those things then great... You want it bad enough... If not then you have more work to do....
I can say I wanted it bad enough and yes I was lucky and fortunate... I was in the same pool as thousands of others... This was how I did it... Maybe it will work for others... Best of luck