Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Well, everyone except Yip anyway.bobbysamd said:Go to a two-year school, earn an A.S. in Aviation and your ratings. Then, transfer to a four-year school and earn a Bachelor's in something else. That way, all bases will be covered and everyone will be happy.
Not true. Here again, Yip, anything that can hone thought processes, such as studying, learning, thinking and analyzing, has everything to do with being a better pilot. Good study skills have everything to do with getting through company ground school. Getting through college fosters development of good study skills.pilotyip said:I really do not care if a pilot does a four-year degree or not, it is an individual choice. It is not for everyone and it has nothing to do with flying an airplane.
The "too often" is baloney. Your claim of $100K success with no need for college sounds like flight school and afternoon TV career school hype. It is misleading, and not realistic without credentials to support it.My point is if you like to fly airplanes, fly airplanes. You will be successful. Without a college degree $100K in 10-12 years out of high school is doable. I see it happen too often.
It may not fall into the four-year-degree program, but it is still not high school only, and the four-year-degree still will be needed, eventually.Spend 2 years at a CC, get your certs and start flying. This is a viable career option, but it still falls in the non- 4-yr degree program.
Define "small." But, three in the broader scope of thousands of pilots, employed and unemployed, qualified and unqualified, college educated or not, is not many at all. These people are the exception, not the rule.pilotyip said:According to Webster’s "Often" means many, what defines many? Is three at a small company many?
My definition of success has nothing to do with political correctness, and everything to do with actually understanding why I do what I do in flying as well as life. Merely going through the monkey motions and performing skills at the braying moron rote level is failure defined, even if it comes with a $100k paycheck.pilotyip said:The individual defines success and not what the majority thinks is politically correct definition of success.
"If a prospective pilots just loves flying airplanes, and would be happy making $70-$100K per year with no debt from college loans, a college degree is not necessary."pilotyip said:To continue the discussion of the merits of the college degree. It has been posted that I am anti-college degree. Nothing cold is further from the truth. The country needs all the college educated citizens it can have, its raises the level of knowledge to keep this as the greatest country in the world. Real degrees in business, engineering, the sciences, math, and medicine provide a graduate with marketable skills. If you are going to go to college, get a real degree from a real university. Do not spend four years getting a degree in Women’s Studies. However this is not an engineering forum, this is an aviation forum. The college degree has nothing to do with flying an airplane. Many have posted they agree it has nothing to do with the mastering on an airplane. I have admitted that the possession of a degree may open doors at a few select places of employment in the airline industry. If a potential pilot feels they will only be pleased in life if they get an interview with UPS, then that prospective pilot should go to college, however disappointment may follow. Air Inc advertises that 166 airlines and assorted aviation companies are recruiting right now, I only see five that make the degree a showstopper. My assertion that runs contrary to the "College is a must” crowd, is that to be competitive for the other 161 places the degree is not necessary. If a prospective pilots just loves flying airplanes, and would be happy making $70-$100K per year with no debt from college loans, a college degree is not necessary. Many prospective pilots may be steered into attending college when they are not college material, not because of a lack basic intelligence, but because it is not important to them. These pilots want to get on with their lives flying airplanes. I have seen too many non-degreed pilots reach a good career position with out a degree. But then my focus is on job satisfaction and not upon pay, respect, and prestige. It is about the joy of flying an airplane. Others out there may feel the same motivation I do.
No, and I do hope that you realize the difference. I am saying that I am smarter, better, and more capable of making critical decisions than I would have been if I had not been to college. Nice try though.pilotyip said:Are you telling me you are smarter, a better pilot, a personal more capable of making critical decisions than my friend and co-worker who is a DC-9 Captain with 4 jets of TJ PIC, who possess and A&P certificate but does not have a college degree? Alternatively, you are better that an Army HS to Flight school graduate with service in Gulf I, who not possess a college degree? It that what you are saying?
Moved AND seconded.Goose Egg said:No, and I do hope that you realize the difference. I am saying that I am smarter, better, and more capable of making critical decisions than I would have been if I had not been to college. Nice try though.
I don't know of its "rating," but I went to Mountain View College in Dallas, TX. Finished the AAS Aviation Technology Aircraft Dispatch, AAS Aviation Technology Professional Pilot, and AS Business Administration in 2 1/2 years. Transfered the Biz stuff to UT Arlington and will be graduating this May with a BBA in Management.Flightjock30 said:I mentor several student pilots in my hometown and one asked me about reputable community college aviation programs? Obviously for four year aviation colleges Embry Riddle, UND, and Purdue are top notch as well as several more.
The real advantage I see to going to a community college flight program is that you usually graduate after two years with all of your ratings (CFI tickets too!) rather than four years. You could begin instructing right at 20-21 years old in that case. Another advantage if you could transfer those credits to a 4 year college and major in something other than aeronautical science in the end to have a backup.
My question therefore is: Does anyone know of the top rated community college aviation programs in the US?
Hell yeah. I graduated a year ago from good old Mt. SACEnglish said:
Pretty interesting statement to say the least..... I have never flown with any one pilot who would ever state they are a "better" and a safer pilot due to that piece of paper called a degree. To even think a long those lines would be on the verge of insanity. Those who have a degree are more capable of "making critical decisions" versus those who do not have the degree?!?!. I have heard some funny things on this board but that has got to be up near the top. That college degree does not make one any safer, better, or a more well rounded pilot, in reality it simply allows you to fill in the box on the application, nothing more and nothing less.Goose Egg said:No, and I do hope that you realize the difference. I am saying that I am smarter, better, and more capable of making critical decisions than I would have been if I had not been to college. Nice try though.
-Goose
If a degree is just a "check the box" item for you, then you are simply missing the point, although I back bobby's opinion that a pilot candidate with a degree has a better shot at getting a job than one without, box-checking notwithstanding.350DRIVER said:That college degree does not make one any safer, better, or a more well rounded pilot, in reality it simply allows you to fill in the box on the application, nothing more and nothing less.
The real question is how "sharp" would the degreed pilots be if they had not been to college, and how "sharp" could the non-degreed pilots be if they had attended. I suppose that the answer to this lies in one thing that pilotyip stated a little while back--it is up to the individual; I have seen many a college student squander their opportunities for learning, merely doing the bare minimum to get through their classes. At the same time, I have seen many non-college student types show superior intelligence and resourcefulness (my claim was never that those two attributes were exclusive to college attendees.)350DRIVER said:I have flown with many pilots who haven't attended a single college class and they were just as sharp as those with the degree. I can't even believe I am taking the time to respond to this, it is insane.
I absolutely agree.350Driver said:Degree or no degree you are still required to show a certain level of competence and ability regardless of whether or not you have that piece of paper.
Yes, but hired where? If one wants the best possible job, then they must posess the best possible credentials. There is a not-so-subtle difference between absolute hiring minimums and competetive minimums.350driver said:Many have been hired without the degree and many more will be, the trend won't be coming to an end anytime soon...but if you are unable then don't think for one second that you will not get hired within this industry, that would be nonsense to buy into that.
No doubt about it. But, I still maintain that anything one can do to improve one's analytical and critical thinking skills can do nothing but improve one's piloting skills. I certainly learned a lot about critical thinking in college, which, I feel has served me during my life and especially while flying. I still remember the talk my instructor gave me about how learning to fly is a course in decision-making, so, I like to feel that those skills were somewhat developed before I started to fly.qmaster3 said:A good friend of mine is a one of those dreaded non-degreed retired US Air types. I can assure you he educated many degreed aviators on the line. Yes, he can make decisions in the bird when those critical moments that we all hate pop up.
Goose, I don't think I am missing the point here at all... I am merely stating that a non-degreed pilot still has opportunity from within this industry to get hired, it happens every day. As I have stated on numerous occasions, I have nothing against the degree and I am all for people who have the financial means, time, etc, to continue on and get the degree, more power to them. I just don't buy into when someone attempts to tell me that a pilot without a degree is less of a skilled pilot and lacks in making "critical decisions" as one poster put it. The degree has nothing to do with your ability to safely and competently operate a piece of equipment.If a degree is just a "check the box" item for you, then you are simply missing the point, although I back bobby's opinion that a pilot candidate with a degree has a better shot at getting a job than one without, box-checking notwithstanding.
I think this is more up to the pilot's background, experience, and flying job history more so than whether they have the degree or not. You could have obtained a PHD, still isn't going to make you a better or safer pilot without real world experience. A better well versed and marketable pilot on paper?. I could probably agree with that but I would take the 5000 hour non-degreed pilot with 1500 turbine pic any day of the week over the PHD with minimal flight experience.The real question is how "sharp" would the degreed pilots be if they had not been to college, and how "sharp" could the non-degreed pilots be if they had attended. I suppose that the answer to this lies in one thing that pilotyip stated a little while back--it is up to the individual; I have seen many a college student squander their opportunities for learning, merely doing the bare minimum to get through their classes. At the same time, I have seen many non-college student types show superior intelligence and resourcefulness (my claim was never that those two attributes were exclusive to college attendees.)
I could not disagree with the above, very well put. The degree does allow one to be more "marketable" on paper, I have always said this.My point: College provides almost limitless opportunities for learning, growth, maturity, and refining of judgement if those opportunities are taken full advantage of. And gaining those skills and attributes is something that I feel is in everyone's long-term best interest, to say nothing of increased employability and competitiveness in the job market. This applies no matter what career field is chosen.
Where?. It happens at many places. Quite a few regionals, some majors, many 91/135 flight departments.Yes, but hired where? If one wants the best possible job, then they must posess the best possible credentials. There is a not-so-subtle difference between absolute hiring minimums and competetive minimums.
No one "attempted" to tell you that. My claim is that education is relative, and that everyone is at a different phase, and that I am a much better pilot than I would have been because of my college education. I fail to see how an expanded knowledge base and skill set would hinder a person, regardless of where their current flying abilities stand. Everyone can improve.350DRIVER said:I just don't buy into when someone attempts to tell me that a pilot without a degree is less of a skilled pilot and lacks in making "critical decisions" as one poster put it. The degree has nothing to do with your ability to safely and competently operate a piece of equipment.
Ahem, this may shoot holes all over my argument, but I can think of a dozen PhDs that I wouldn't trust within 50 yds. of an airplane. And I say that as a CFI and a college graduate.350DRIVER said:You could have obtained a PHD, still isn't going to make you a better or safer pilot without real world experience. A better well versed and marketable pilot on paper?. I could probably agree with that but I would take the 5000 hour non-degreed pilot with 1500 turbine pic any day of the week over the PHD with minimal flight experience.
This board, and life in general.350DRIVER said:Take things with a grain of salt that you read on this board.
(emphasis added)Goose Egg said:[W]ith all of you guys constantly moaning and groaning about how hard it is to make a living in this business and how competetive it is, I would seek every advantage to make myself attractive to an employer. And some folks here actively promote to the younger members of the forum that they should not participate in an activity, i.e. a college education, that increases their likelihood of getting their desired job, and I think it is reckless and irresponsible. Face it, 4 years is going to go by regardless, and no one is going to get a TJPIC job right out of high school... or college for that matter.
Forget not having a "plan B" with an aviation degree. Try falling back on a high school education . . . .