The OSU incident I remember was a TWA 707 landing there instead of CMH. They used to have pictures of it hanging in the greasy spoon there when I flew corporate. Has it happened more than once there with a legacy carrier?
Same thing almost happened to me at the exact same airport about nine years ago. We were at the end of a six or seven leg day and were coming in from Chicago Midway back to Columbus. It was night with a high overcast and when we descended through it my F/O (pilot flying) calls the airport in sight. I gave that info to approach and they cleared us for the visual.
Suddenly my F/O starts to nose over into a fairly steep decent. I look out at the runway in front of us and my tired brain is telling me something is not right here. I look at the FMS and it looks like we are not lined up for the airport. Not trusting the FMS completely (with no GPS they constantly go DR on us.) I quickly dial in the localizer and select green needles. I then realize we are lined up for OSU! We went around and continued on to CMH and I did not hear a peep out of ATC.