A cocky pilot... no?
Well, I think that if you need to find the best pilots in the world just walk around the university campus sometime at SIU and you will find dozens, just ask them. I know exactly where you come from, however, in their defense I would rather have a pilot that is slightly on the cocky side than one without confidence at all. I know this is from the training aspect of it, in the airlines I cannot comment. Pilots are generally ego-centric, but I find the best way to deal with them is to kill them with kindness. They will make a mistake eventually and when they realize what they did it will hurt five times more. And generally there is nothing more humbling when your instructor that is 2 or 3 years younger than you smiling from the right seat reminding you of simple procedures you forgot.
Oh, and a comment for Bluffs4U, in your little signature profile to the left it says..
"ATP of course" isn't that a bit cocky in itself?? Like of course you hold an ATP your all holliness!