BluDevAv8r said:
This is always a heated issue but here goes anyway...The TWA/AA deal was not a merger of two viable companies - it was an acquisition by a relatively healthy company (AA) of an "about to be Chapter 7" company (TWA). The staple job occurred because Carty required it as a condition of acquisition. Big difference from what would happen if CAL merged with someone (say UAL for argument's sake). Career expectations would be taken into account under ALPA merger policy and it would not be the staple job that you saw at AA/TWA.
-Neal
Duck!
Actually, Neal, Carty did not really have any say in the integration process at all. He left the APA and ALPA to work it out on their own, at which point ALPA decided to bow out of the game (since they were busy trying to recruit AA into their ranks), and the APA pretty much did whatever they wanted.
Carty and the APA did agree that TWA pilots had to waive their rights to third party neutral arbitration as a condition of employment at AA, which is where I believe the TWA pilots got the worst screwing. Neutral arbitration is the only fair way to settle a dispute bewteen two pilot groups when it comes to integrations. The APA did not want to play fair, but the question can be made as to whether they were required to - when a non ALPA airline merges with another airline with a different union, these things happen (and have happened before - reference the SWA acquisition of Morris and where those pilots ended up - all stapled.)
Once that happened, the APA did use their own formula for "career expectations" which resulted in the creation of Supplement CC (STL protected fence for TWA pilots) and the highly controversial staple job of approximately 1100 TWA pilots, with the remaining 1200 feathered in at 8:1.
As far as an ALPA-ALPA merger, as I've said before, the only three outcomes would be DOH, relative seniority or ratio integration - all provided courtesy of your neutral arbitrator. At the very least, when all is said and done, you can only blame the arbitrator, and not the other pilot group.
Have fun at CAL, Neal... I've got a serious case of "grass is greener" right now!
73