And now for the serious answer......
Superior hats (Midway Hat Company) stand up higher in the front and are of much cheaper quality. They do tend to fall apart faster and fade worse. You'll definately look like a porter or bellhop while wearing one. The only positive thing about a Superior is that the inner front part that holds the hat up can be replaced. It's made of plastic, and swaps out easier.
Bancroft is a much better quality hat, sits lower in the front, and is more comfortable (if such a thing exists). The emblem also seems to fit better on the Bancroft than on the other hat. The drawback is the front support. It's made of something, not quite sure, and can't be replaced. I've had mine for 5 years and haven't had an issue with it, but if you don't take care of it, that's another story.
Bancrofts have been hard to come by lately for some reason. I've been trying to get a new one for 2 months now and can't. I refuse to buy a Superior just to have a hat on my head, so I guess I'm rebeling now. All I need now is spiked hair, an Ipod, and a backpack and I'll be just fine, Mr. Hand.