I'm with Viking on this one. Alaska was (at the time) my first, and only choice of majors. This would naturally infer that I DID NOT want to work anywhere else.
Personally I believe their "paranoia" over people leaving their organization has tainted the hiring process. There will always be some normal attrition at any carrier, but if you become a "control freak" on the front end of the hiring process you might just end up with people who don't want to be at your company any more than the next guy, they just gave you better "BS". I'm not trying to say anything negative about ANY Alaska new hire, but some of the least trustyworthy people I have known are great at spewing out BS and interview really well. Again, this is supposed to be a comment directed at the logic the company is using for the interview format, not directed at anyone they have hired.
I do not see a real need for the second interview. In an attempt to "probe for areas of concern" I was asked some crazy questions that didn't even make sense. The person was arrogantly talking about their particular area of concern and had absolutely no idea what they were talking about. There is a fine line between doing your job as a professional and being rude and unprofessional. In my opinion they crossed the line beyond what I consider appropriate. This interview was more of a "cross-examination" than an interview.
Before aviation I worked for a decade in the field of Human resources and can assure you that this "good cop-bad cop" interview technique has not been used by most large corporations since the early 1970's.
I also did not see any core values illustrated to me in the second. They should not have to apologize for "beating you up" at the end of the interview- that in itself tells you something. Lastly, if they like you they call you within a day or two. If they dont, you never hear back from them by phone or mail, which puts everyone in an uncomfortable position if you have to call them back.
IT IS JUST BUSINESS, but its hard to not take it personally when one goes through the entire process to be treated poorly at the final stage. A simple "no thanks" form letter would be an easy answer to this problem. Caring IS in theory a core value...........