YourPilotFriend
YourPilotFriend
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2005
- Posts
- 1,570
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
At least part of SWAPA was. I think the last vote was something like 55-45.
A question to those of you angry at ALPA: did you participate in the survey? Are you aware that not even 50% of the membership even bothered to vote in the survey? I think Prater has handled this horribly, and I disagree with ALPA's current position on this issue, but the fact of the matter is that the membership didn't even bother to get involved in this.
So what is his motive?
Why do people keep paying ALPA dues if they're so unhappy with the union?
It seems like there are a lot of people who don't like ALPA, but are they the majority? If they are, why don't they try to decertify ALPA at their respective airlines? The US Airways guys are giving it a shot (anybody know what happened with that?).
This is NOT flame bait. Just a question from an outsider looking in.
Thanks.
Skyward80
My membership status reads "inactive," so I don't really think that's my place. The active membership needs to rise up and demand accountable representation. Prater seems to think that he is above the will of the membership, and someone needs to teach him that that's not the case. It won't be me, however, unless my carrier's union merges into ALPA someday. (something that would now be harder to accomplish thanks to Prater alienating an even larger portion of the industryDocument your case... put it together..... start a website...
You are correct but that's not the whole story. Of those that did vote the overwhelming majority did not want to change the rule.
5 more years at $500,000 plus bennies?
Dues payments are not voluntary. If you don't pay the union can have you terminated.
Great system huh?
The "majority of the minority" elects all politicians, including the President of the United States, in this country. Are those elections all invalid in your mind simply because the true majority of the population didn't participate? Sorry, it doesn't work that way. The membership spoke. Prater ignored them, then stabbed them in the back. I will continue to support ALPA because I believe strongly in the Association, but I look forward to the day that Prater is kicked out on his ass.The majority of the minority?
My membership status reads "inactive," so I don't really think that's my place.
The active membership needs to rise up and demand accountable representation.
Prater seems to think that he is above the will of the membership, and someone needs to teach him that that's not the case.
It won't be me, however, unless my carrier's union merges into ALPA someday.
(something that would now be harder to accomplish thanks to Prater alienating an even larger portion of the industry)
The "majority of the minority" elects all politicians, including the President of the United States, in this country.
Are those elections all invalid in your mind simply because the true majority of the population didn't participate? Sorry, it doesn't work that way.
The membership spoke.
Prater ignored them, then stabbed them in the back. I will continue to support ALPA because I believe strongly in the Association, but I look forward to the day that Prater is kicked out on his ass.
True, all pilots industry-wide are affected by ALPA, but only the members of the Association have a place in directing the Association's policy (which, as you know, is why I think all pilots should be members of ALPA). In my opinion, it simply isn't appropriate for non-members to attempt to affect internal affairs of the Association.Why not. Your effected by it.
I think his actions on this issue make it clear that he does feel he is above the will of the membership. Who's gonna teach him that he's not? Probably no one. The same apathetic membership that did nothing to stop this early on will do nothing to put Prater in his place. As always, the problems begin and end with the apathetic membership.Not sure if he thinks he is above the will.... who's gonna teach him?
So are you now admitting that Oberstar's bill would not have been put to a vote had it not been for ALPA's support?ALPA was THE main player on this Age 60 fiasco.</p>
You know I agree with that. The problem is that most pilots don't. I've done enough organizing work to know that trying to convince pilots to join an Association that they perceive as not representing the will of the membership is nearly impossible. Prater has dealt a huge blow to the image of the Association to rank-and-file pilots both inside and outside of the Association. He's certainly not helping ALPA's effort to recruit new members.Valid point.... however, yet another reason to join ALPA. ALPA is changing the retirement age for all pilots mind as well join and fix it..
.So are you now admitting that Oberstar's bill would not have been put to a vote had it not been for ALPA's support?
You know I agree with that. The problem is that most pilots don't. I've done enough organizing work to know that trying to convince pilots to join an Association that they perceive as not representing the will of the membership is nearly impossible. Prater has dealt a huge blow to the image of the Association to rank-and-file pilots both inside and outside of the Association. He's certainly not helping ALPA's effort to recruit new members.
What is the difference between his CAL income and retirement and his ALPA Pres......baby?
Kinda like our tax system... how many would not pay taxes?
Should we include his $7500 a month living allowance? But, ignoring that paltry sum he has to live on, I would say at least $300k to $350K difference and increase for his lofty position.
Additionally, please don't call me baby. I prefer to only let the guy I am letting drill me use that callsign.
Somehow, I don't ever picture you in that position.![]()
Well, you wouldn't get fired from your citizenship just put in jail. Using your very weak analogy with ALPA's methods, structure and loss of vision, I would suspect many would prefer jail than funding their own continued destruction.
It would be easier for you to just cut and paste one of your millions of responses of how it is the memberships fault.
Last one out turn out the lights. I think this will be the beginning of the end for ALPA.
Got a source?
C'mon Austin Powers convinced Agent Kensington to allow him to call her Vanessa..... baby... (oops)
Point is there are consequences. In fact, you are more free to choose the consequences of not paying dues then taxes. Born in this country you have to pay taxes... or renounce citizenship.... you going to have to pay taxes somehwere... if you don't want ot pay ALPA dues then don't join.
Union structure is modeled after American democracy. As Austin Powers said... 'Right not we've got freedom and responsibility... its a groovy time...'
No... I've got my issues with the leadership, but I think the membership should deal with thier reposnsibilites first...
And then what? What about your career?
Just because you most likely look like Austin Powers doesn't mean that you should mimic him. Be warned, the last blowhard that used that line to me in a bar and grabbed me got a swift kneecap right in the balls. Maybe you are into that type of sexual activity and gratification I don't know.
LOL, not an option to not join. I wonder what would happen if everyone said FU, I'm not paying?
ALPA is not a democracy.
You can start with the above
What career? ALPA has turned this into a job.
Top. I wonder how the rest of the ALPA membership feels about these salaries and benefits?