I was asked by someone from another board to post this here:
All,
Age 60 is contentious; but it also has to be resolved. I propose the following reasonable compromise based on the following understandings.
Bob turns age 60 on Nov 15th 2008. The Cap Age is still 61 at this point; but Bob's going to turn age 61 on Nov 15th 2009 which carries him through the 61 + 3 month year (see table above) and into the 61 + 6 year, therefore Bob works the extra six months and retires on May 15th 2010.
Let's not forget Sally who happens to turn 60 on Jan 1st 2008. The Cap Age is 61 in that year making her new date Jan 1st of 2009; but wait, she now hits '09 giving her the 61+3 Cap Age. She turns 61+3 on about 1 April '09 and she retires on that date.
Now this kind of proposal if not perfect; but it does smooth out transition years and it is MORE inclusive of pilots that fall just on the wrong side of the magic date.
Standing by for incoming...
Let's keep it civil please.
All,
Age 60 is contentious; but it also has to be resolved. I propose the following reasonable compromise based on the following understandings.
- A snap change of age 60 to any other higher age is a windfall to those lucky enough to catch the extra ride
- A snap change of age 60 holds all pilots below the lucky few to a junior position for the full length of the extended age (5 years in the case of 65)
- Pilots who miss the date by just a day lose the whole benefit of the change
- Pilots already past age 60 also gain 0 benefit from the change
- Set a moving retirement age soon starting at age 61 which will progress upward at a rate of three months per year until there is either no retirement age or a maximum age is reached. We'll call this age the "Cap Age"
- Allow any pilot under the Cap Age to return to work within the first year.
- All pilots must retire at the Cap Age
- Given: the proposed law goes into effect on Jan 1st 2008
- Given: the new Cap Age is 61 until Jan 1st 2009
- Given: the Cap Age will adjust upward by three months each successive Jan 1st until either the maximum Cap Age is reached (say 65) or until there is no practical Cap Age
- Cap Age Table:
- Jan 1st 2008 -- Cap Age = 61
- Jan 1st 2009 -- Cap Age = 61+3 months
- Jan 1st 2010 -- Cap Age = 61+6 months
- Jan 1st 2011 -- Cap Age = 61+9 months
- Jan 1st 2012 -- Cap Age = 62
- Jan 1st 2013 -- Cap Age = 62+3 months
- Jan 1st 2014 -- Cap Age = 62+6 months
- etc. until max reached or until no limit...
Bob turns age 60 on Nov 15th 2008. The Cap Age is still 61 at this point; but Bob's going to turn age 61 on Nov 15th 2009 which carries him through the 61 + 3 month year (see table above) and into the 61 + 6 year, therefore Bob works the extra six months and retires on May 15th 2010.
Let's not forget Sally who happens to turn 60 on Jan 1st 2008. The Cap Age is 61 in that year making her new date Jan 1st of 2009; but wait, she now hits '09 giving her the 61+3 Cap Age. She turns 61+3 on about 1 April '09 and she retires on that date.
Now this kind of proposal if not perfect; but it does smooth out transition years and it is MORE inclusive of pilots that fall just on the wrong side of the magic date.
Standing by for incoming...
Let's keep it civil please.