My info's a little dated, having last taught at Tyndall 5 years ago, but I doubt that things have changed much, so here goes:
Hugh Jordan -- You're right, these three guys in no way represent a cross section of a typical B-course. I wouldn't be surprised if Love and Gregory were the only two Capts in the class -- there were usually only one or two. Giggy also isn't typical being a newlywed -- the majority of the Lts are single. You can see that CBS is going for the human interest side to get as much "family" involvement as possible. If they'd followed a typical single Lt b-course student around they'd have gotten Squadron--Gym--Bar--
Q-room --- not exactly something you can build a 1/2 season show around.
1900cpt -- There was a guy like Giggy that showed up in about 1/2 the classes -- watched Top Gun one too many times I guess. The IPs would zero in on him pretty quickly for an "attitude adjustment." A good B-courser has to be confident, but also has to be a sponge -- there's just too much information in too little time. Too much cockiness and they just don't absorb everything they need to.
Now what's not typical at all is Giggy's performance so far. It was VERY rare for a student to bust an academic test -- they were in-depth, but not at all tricky. The guys that failed tended to be ones that didn't put in the required study time (too much time waterskiing at Mexico Beach and playing with the new wife, I guess). The other rarity is the two sim busts prior to the first flight -- just didn't happen (even though Monte Cooper has a reputation as one the most "demanding" sim instructors).
With all that, my money's that Giggy's going to make it through the program. There's no way CBS is going to have one of the "stars" wash out in the first two or three episodes. Now I'm not in the know at all (been non-flying for 2 years now), but it wouldn't suprise me if Giggy ends up getting one of the awards at graduation -- stranger things have happened.
Just my opinions,
Zulu
"Free the Stop Loss Hostages"