I think it is good to measure a man by what aircraft he is currently flying. The problem, however, is what kind of value does a certain aircraft pin to that person's total quality? Should it be by size? Then a B747 pilot is, like way, way better than, say, a DC-9 pilot and exponentially better than some mildly retarded scum-bag Lear 23 pilot. Or, should it be by the quality of automation of one's aircraft? That would mean that the movie stars that get to fly the new 787 can walk around signing autographs, while that -9 guy must hang his head in shame...OR it could be the inverse of that where the folks that fly the highly automated airplanes should hang their heads in shame and the -9 guys/LR23 guys can walk around, head held high with their chests in "auto-puff"? Has ALPA given any guidance about whom can act cooler than whom based on aircraft flown? Does the "quality" build up in that person like points and you never lose them, or do you lose them when you go from one airplane to another? If so, how can I tell how to treat someone when I see them in the terminal? How can I tell what aircraft that person has flown in his career?
How about comparing airline to airline to judge the quality of a pilot? Then the freight haulers in DC-8's should have less quality and skill than the B777 pax driver? What about if your airline used to be the place to work, but now it is not, like UAL or TWA, or Pan Am? Did that whole group of pilots used to be quality people but now they are not?
I once had a boeing pilot ask me about the airbus? "Meh, it's OK" says I. "It is pretty comfortable I guess" says I. He then goes into a story about how much easier it is to change out (insert some part like HYD pump, or Fuel pump, or some other part I don't remember) on his boeing than my airbus. He would be long airborn whilst we would still be stuck at the gate. I thought that was a great bragging right. I just wish I could remember what part it was that was hypothetically changed.
Could someone chime in here to give guidance on how we can discern who is of better qualtiy than whom?