It depends on what measuring stick you use...
If you look at ALPA in terms of what is the organization doing for me right now, then you can look at those tangible items.
What you don't see what ALPA does for the profession is much more profound. But in order to "see" you have to look. You have to activate.
ALPA is a political organization, not personal assistant to your career. ALPA doesn't wash you, put on your uniform and open coach door like a 18th Century Lordship would be treated....
There are many things that ALPA does nationally and internationally that most pilots don't know about. Why? Because pilot refuse to get connected. There are forces and changes occuring constantly, such as Open Skies, that effect your career. What do you know about Open Skies?
There are events, such as making a terrorist act akin to striking, that are stopped that you don't hear about, but if a legal job action were equating to an act of terrorism then you ability to negotiate a better BA would be seriously hampered..
Also, there is an expectation of ALPA, whether it is real or not, that ALPA is supposed to protect ones career. Well, yes, but it is not that simple and easy. In addition, management and the FAA doesn't have an obligation to listen to a pilots concern. ALPA does.
I appreciate your answer. I agree with you. I know ALPA has done more then just try to provide better TA for the pilots. I just don't think that ALPA alone made those changes. They only occurred because the pilot group spoke up about it. I strong believe that if we have a major issue today, the pilots can speak up and could get things done, regardless if you're ALPA, teamster, SAPA, Southwest Union, etc.
I don't have anything against ALPA. At Mesa(my previous airline) things were bad, but they would have been much worst without ALPA. I just don't understand this "fever" about getting ALPA on Skywest. I don't drink the koolaid they give us here, I just simply think with ALPA things will take a turn for the worst.
I said it once and I will say again. If you can prove to me things will be better here with ALPA around, I will vote tomorrow morning.