I heard something different on that pay vote where the "deal Brad an ace" statement was used. While a lot of pilots' selective ears heard
"Vote for this temporary less than ideal pay raise where 50-99 seat pay was the same, and you'll see a big raise next time",
that's not what I heard. What I heard was
"Vote for this pay package and the company will have the flexibility to attract more flying which will result in faster progression to the left seat which means more pay for you - not in the scale but in your progress through the scale."
I never heard anyone from SAPA or the managment team say otherwise. By the way, looking at the fleet structure before and after that vote, I think they delivered on that promise. Similarly, there may be some who are hearing the OC say,
"Vote ALPA in and life will be great",
even though the OC is not saying that. We often hear what we want to hear and not what people are saying. I think if ALPA is voted in, the OC will deliver on their promises but will fall short of what many of the pilots expected.