With the way things are going now with airlines throwing pension plans out the window, I would rather have a good 401k match and profit sharing bonus that goes to the employee so you control it and can't have it taken away which sounds like exactly what SWA has. But on the other hand when times where good at the UAL, USAIR and the pensions there where still ongoing, could it be said that those pension out weighed the SWA 401k match and profit sharing bonus by a huge margin. If a retired UAL pilot was getting 150,000 a year from UAL in a pension where as SWA pilot who retired the same day got Zero from that point on, this must save SWA Billions a year by not having a defined pension plan. With all the concessions and now pensions possibly going away at the Legacy airlines, I would think that the legacy carriers are soon going to be very competitve with the likes of SWA, Jet Blue, Airtran. The pay for similiar equipment is very close, (some new LCC have a lot less years of service for pay rates with CAPTand FO's on 5-8 year pay vs. a UAL 737 CAPTor FO on 15yr pay)but they will catch up in 5 plus years) and with the savings of no pensions to pay the retirement benefits would be very close to the same having 401k match etc. there are still alot of others factors but, when the playing field becomes even then what will happen?