Of course I am going to respond! You're still wrong. 1st, I think there is confusion as to what question the guy answering the question is being asked. Here is the answer he gives, "The applicant does not qualify under 61.63(e)(4)(ii)(A) or under 61.157(g)(3)(ii)(A) to take a 100% practical test in a simulator for the CE‑650 type rating. "
The question was about whether the SOE would be removed, not whether he could take a 100% ride in the sim. The guy didnt even answer the right question.
Also, I don't know what other things the PART 142 schools use, but at the FSI and especially Simuflite, anyone who hits the door can take a 100% ride in the sim. Whth the modern technology, it's the sim itself that is limiting. not the canidate. As long as it is level C or D, the entire ride can be accomplished in the sim. With anything less that C or D, circiling approachs cannot be accomplished because of the level of graphics, so if all you have is a level A orB, then the aircraft is used to complete those items.
Also, in reading the website that you referenced, it specifically states that these answers are not legal answers, just opinions of the author. Even thought he works for the FAA, he has his own opinion, but let's face it, it's not the one that counts. Obviusly it's not the one that counts as 142 schools are operating in a menner different that what this guy is suggesting. Everybody has their own opinion. Call any 2 FSDOs with the same question, and you'll get 2 different answers. The best place to go is the Training provider. Each FSi is governed by it's local FSDO, so things are going to be different between any 2 FSI. Technically, it might be skirting the FARs by using their own wording, but it is because of that wording that allows this practive to be legal. No matter what you or anyone else says, this practice occurs on a regular basis.
Finally, my friends Names: Mike Hunt and Anita Goodwon. Feel free to pass their names on to whoever you need to pass them on to, but I can assure you it wil not make any difference.