I will probably catch some cr@p from the guys that bought the Scott Leather products, and I kick myself for not doing what I should have done. Bottom line: I got the "other" pub case from the school house from LuggageWorks... it $uck$, don't buy it!
That being said, I still don't think you need to spend $400 on a Scott Leather chart case. What I should have done is get the 18" or 20" Korchmar case. I've used them before and they're great (didn't use my old Korchmar for SWA because I had the 16" case from working at SkyWest and it doesn't fit too much stuff, albiet perfect in an EMB-120, SWA pubs require more room.)
Korchmar cases can be bought online through several vendors. And here's the best part. They are called "Catalog Cases." Apparently when you market these things as "Pilot Chart Cases" you can mark up the price to close to $400!! But if you call it a "Catalog Case" (for business types) they'll run you about $250. I can just see an exchange between you (new SWA pilot) and a salesman in a store: You - "Hi, I'd like to buy a catalog case." Sales guy - "Sure! We have these really nice leather cases for $250." You - "Great, I'll take it! That'll work perfect in the cockpit." Sales guy - "Oh, are you a pilot? Well, we will have to charge you $400 for that 'pilot' case."
Enough ranting... here are some links:
http://www.1stdiscountluggage.com/korleatspecc.html
http://www.casestore.com/detail.asp?i=15 (best price online, so far)
http://www.casestore.com/detail.asp?i=16 (this one is the 20" for extra $$$)
http://www.ebags.com/product_detail/index.cfm?ModelID=17041# (from E-bags... good company discount. Just wait until you get your employee number before ordering.)
http://www.ebags.com/product_detail/index.cfm?ModelID=17030 (this is a great price... a bit big for the guppy though)
http://shopluggageplanet.safeshopper.com/168/1740.htm?522
Happy shopping and just remember... this advice is free and you probably got what you paid for.