You know my friend, and I know, that this SHAMeful line of events has put a lot of them in a very uncomfortable position and it was done deliberately. KNOWING that is what makes it hard to back off of them even ONE INCH.
But here's the kicker: no one WANTS to be reasonable after the nut-kicking they've been receiving daily since this started. Reasonable went out the door a long time ago, right about the time the judge ruled that the holding company could keep the money away from the people that earned it.
So in order to even have some SEMBLANCE of reasonability, these guys are going to have to see some serious payback as the company grows more healthy, and I don't mean "just back to previous levels", I mean "seats on the Bod, bonuses to flight crews when management takes them, snap-back pay protections based on PERFORMANCE targets, not easily-manipulated RASM figures.
So maybe the slogan can be, "we can give you JUST THIS ONE dime, but we fu*king want a quarter back at the very first showing that you have it to give", then we will continue to earn that quarter again on a regular basis as we perform to these accepted standards.
Give 'em what they want, but make it hurt like hell on the other end and make d*mned sure that "other end" is in the next 2-3 years (short-term).