185flyer,
I have read this thread from start to end, and I agree with the others: I think it would behoove you to step back and be quiet. You are offering opinions on subjects that you know nothing about.
It would be like me going in to a hospital and telling the doctors how easy they have it, how I think a surgery should be performed, etc.
You say you have a right to your opinion, but how can you even formulate an opinion on issues that you are so ignorant about? A 200 hour private pilot spouting off opinions and trying to educate airline pilots who ARE in the thick of it is a waste of time and a confession of stupidity.
I am a military type, and until I got to the airlines, I too thought low of unions. In the military mind, especially the Marines, you did your job and that was that. The job got done, you were taken care of, and that's how it was. The officers had to make sure certain things happened, the NCO's and nonrates made these things happen, and it was all a cooperative and mutually respected relationship.
But something I found out quickly was that a union is necessary in the airlines and that management will thrive on any weakness in a pilot group whether it is their own pilot group or another airlines group that "lowers the bar".
You see, unlike it was in the good ole USMC, people in the upper levels have no respect for the welfare of their subordinates in the airline business. As a staff level NCO, I would see to it that my Marines were fed, rested adeqautely, and equipped. THEN, and only when they "got theirs" would I get mine. This is not so in the airlines. In the airlines, management gets theirs first, then tells you that there is not enough to go around for you. Even if there is plenty to go around, they will tell you that it's too bad because "well, XYZ airline's pilots are doing it for X dollars". Couple this with those who are not even in the job yet telling you "Oh, I'd do it for nothing, I just want to fly a jet". Well, spooge off in your pants for 6 months until the reality of flying a jet, making someone else rich while your wife and kid are wondering how can daddy be gone so much and make no money gets quite old. You have no idea the long, hard, expensive road it takes to get an airline pilot job. Then to be told (and have it published in your state newspaper) that a B757 should max out at $90,000. My brother-in-law got a starting pay offer nearly that at an airline to be a computer programmer! He's only 29!! A pilot is well into their 30's by the time they get a major airline job. Then forced retirement at age 60? How can you pay off the HUGE debt, pay for your house, save for kids college and put into a retirement if you max out at 90 thousand in less than 30 years?
Especially when some kids with low time and NO EXPERIENCE come in and lower the pay you make because they "just want to fly a jet" or "will gladly trade places with you" etc etc. Whores they are....
Please, let those who know what they are talking about educate those who do not. Opinions are worthless until you have some idea what you are talking about. In the meantime, act more like a sponge and try to learn from those who DO know what they are talking about. Perhaps one day it will be YOU who is watching YOUR profession fall apart. See how you feel then. THEN you can give an opinion. In the meantime, to quote a great genius of all times......ZIP IT SCOTTY.....
AND ANOTHER THING....the question about why does a pilot deserve a pension when HP has other groups without one. YOU MUST BE A LIBERAL. Give it all to everyone or no one gets it. How about I don't get to keep my house because someone else out there does not have a house?
Show me a company that gives all it's employees the same package. Pilots are a skilled labor. Rampers, for example, are not a skilled labor. (NO WAY AM I LOWERING YOU RAMPERS, YOU GUYS ARE GREAT) Why doesn't Parker give up his retirement? Use your reason here. Does not work does it? Again, turn off your transmitter and turn on your receiver. Then again, you sound like someone pursuing a management degree. So you probably do not care anyway. Enjoy the 3 houses.