NY...
If you compare hourly rate to hourly rate, it is true SWA and JB do not pay what a UAL, DAL, or AAL pay.
However...depending on date of hire and other variables, there are a lot of guys who are millionares (so I hear) with stock at SWA. There are also annual profit sharing checks that aren't factored into the hourly rate.
Are there any really smart SWA guys who have a "real" handle on annual compensation for Capts and FOs the last few years (Mozam...where are you?). What does the typical 5 year FO and 10 year Capt really make?
Another wrinkle....would you rather work 20 years interupted by furloughs here and there, or work for less and not get laid off? At what point does a guy hired in 1998 by SWA catch or pass a 1998 AAL/UAL/DAL hire based on working verses NOT working? I said it in a previous post--I think many of you look at the HOURLY rate at SWA or JB and say "that's low". However, you may forget the extra money earned here or there with profit sharing, etc.
A/B funds verses stock options is a huge debate. The market may eat your options and stock. On the other hand, going out of business eliminates your retirement pensions. This gut check was one reason I went with Fedex...no guarantees but I really thought the pk of actually making it 23 years to retirement with them staying solvent was pretty good. (But...as any fighter pilot will tell you, nothing has a Pk of 1!)
What really matters to me is how much money do I have at the end of every month/year, and how many days did I have to be away from home to get those dollars. (I may be different here than some...but block time verses hotel time verses ground time is a wash with me...if I'm not at home with family I could really care less as long as I can get a safe/legal rest and good meal). I don't think the average JB or SWA guy leaves mom and the kids much if any more than any other major pilot, and with the various other compensations (at SWA anyway) I think the salary might be closer to the majors than you realize. Certainly the career earnings at some carriers may be lower than the old Air Inc charts in the pay guide, simply because guys are going to be furloughed for a few years or upgrading at a much slower than historical rate.
And for the record...I wish captains all made $500,000 a year. Every new contract that pushes wages up makes life better for all of us. However, the fact is the economy, the internet revolution, and inevitiable competition has put wage pressure on all of us. I think the most successful union groups are going to be the ones that figure out how to get some win-win compensation options from their carriers in the future, tying increased pay to increased profits and revenue. In any case--with my degree in aviation management, its hang tough in this business or wash cars, so I'll see all of you out there while slipping the surlies...
On a lighter note, my newest co-pilot landed today. It'll be 16 years before she can solo, but I'll be busy until then getting things in line for her. Hopefully I'll have a nice Steerman or Waco to train her in by then, but if not maybe she and her 2 sisters will tolerate bouncing around with their dad in a cardinal or tiger.