Race Pilot,
While I respect your opinion, I must disagree with you on a few points. Before doing that though, I want to emphasize that this should not be a battle of active duty vs guard/reserve. When all is said and done, we are all on the same team. If you will look at my previous post, I never once mentioned nor was I trying to imply that stop loss should not happen. I was only trying to make the point that if we are implementing the end of stop loss (for the most part), we should at the same time be deactivating guard and reserve units. This process should go hand in hand.
Now for your points:
(1) You claim that there was a lot of complaining during the gulf war conflict. I was on active duty during that time period serving as an instructor pilot. As such, I did not have any interaction with the guard/reserve, therefore I cannot disclaim what you say. I believe what you say to be true, but at the same time I would hazard a guess that there were plenty of active duty folks who were complaining as well. Do I fault them? Absolutely not, they were in a horrible place during an uncertain time. Although they may not have been complaining about the same things, I'm sure they were complaining none the less.
(2) You also talked about the guard/reserve making two days pay for one day of work. In essence I will agree that we can sometimes make almost two days pay for one day of work, but it doesn't always work out that way. Many times we don't even get a full day of pay when we go into work. On the other hand, when you are in the guard or reserve, you ONLY get paid (last time I checked) when you went into the unit to do duty. When you are in the active duty, you get paid everyday whether you go in to work or not. Now unless you are going into work 30 days per month, I'll bet you are getting paid for some days when you don't go to work. I'm not complaining about that, it's just the way it is. By the way, while on active duty I got my full flight pay every month regardless of how many days I flew. During my first 12 months as a bum in the reserves, I flew almost twice as many hours as I did during my BEST year on active duty, but I never once got my full flight pay for the month. It was always just a percentage of the full amount. Also, you will get to start collecting retirement pay the minute you step out of your uniform for the last time. We don't get to start collecting retirement until we reach age 60. That's quite a few years of "disparity" of income.
(3) As for your point regarding additional duties, there are plenty of pilots in my unit who come in and do duties other than flying. While it doesn't happen as much as on active duty, in all honesty, we shouldn't be expected to do it as much as active duty. If we did, we would have to work around 15+ days per month in our reserve/guard job while at the same time working nearly that much in our civilian job. One thing I learned quickly was that just because I was a reservist, my monthly flying requirements didn't change. I am required to log just as many events as my active duty counterpart to stay current. If I had to do all this flying and at the same time be expected to do numerous additional duties with the unit, and finally, perform my civilian job, I would never have any time left for my family.
(4) We all know what COULD happen when we join the military, whether that be active duty or guard/reserve, and I imagine you would be hard pressed to find anyone who would not volunteer to step up to the plate to defend our country. On the other hand, when members of the guard/reserve perceive they aren't being utilized while in an activated state, they begin to wonder why they are activated in the first place. This is especially true when they start to believe that active duty units doing less than they are doing (i.e. getting released from stop loss while they are locked in to service).
(5) "Now, if a guard or reserve guy has had his papers in since before 9-11 or wants to put them in now to get out, they should let them out just like the active duty guys." I agree completely with this statement. Unfortunately, based on how I read the AFPC message (although I may be interpreting it incorrectly), certain guard/reserve members will not be allowed to get out if they want to get out. At least not immediately.
(6) "With the drawdown of active forces we cannot fight all the battles ourselves. We need help from the "total force"" This my friend is a very dangerous statement. As most of us know, as long as we continue to get involved in location after location without an increase but rather a drawdown of our force we will continue to be spread thinner and thinner. With this in mind, what would you have the guard/reserve do? Should we activate our units on a whim anytime there is even the slightest blip on the radar screen? Should we set up rotations where every reserve/guard unit gets activated for a year every three to four years? I agree that we need to stop the drawdown of active forces and instead we need to bolster these same forces. The question is is the American public ready to fund such a force? I can guarantee you that when you put an undue task on the guard and reserve you will lose members. Whether this is right or not is moot, I can guarantee it WILL happen. What is the answer? That is WAY WAY beyond my pay grade, but obviously something needs to happen.
Let me wrap this up with this, when I joined my unit, I was told that my family came first, then my civilian job, and finally my reserve commitment. I honestly believe that the leadership of my unit felt that way when I joined and they still do. I am not trying to sound like a whiner or complainer, but if the leadership of this country feels like we no longer need a stop loss, and we are getting things under control, then we can obviously allow our reservists and guardsmen to get back to their families and civilian jobs. I am also sorry that it appears you had some bad encounters with guard and reserve members in the past. I can assure you that having been in both worlds, the reservists in my unit are every bit as professional in their reserve jobs as the active duty personnel I have known.
With that I find that I have rambled on far enough. I wish you God speed and safe flying, and I wish you luck in your retirement from active duty service. Thank you for serving this great nation!