Hand Commander said:
Yes! I love it when experienced jumpers land off and after walking back to the dz, proclaim, "what was with that spot? We were in F ing Bolivia!". Then the first question I ask is, "did you look before you got out?" That usually leads to a moment of silence. I would say that the number of times people landed off with me flying and it was entirely my fault would be counted on one hand. I don't intentionally put people off and I pay attention to who's on every load and adjust giving the lights accordingly, but when jumpers exit, I'm assuming they know the score.
Yes, spotting is a lost art. Most large DZ's don't teach anything about spotting. Hell, I started jumping in the days of 180's and 182's with no GPS. We actually used to fly over the DZ at 3k and drop streamers(some called it spotting tape), as well as 6-9k, to get a feel for the REAL winds. Most skydivers these days don't have a clue as to what a streamer is, other than a serious malfunction...but I still have a word with the pilot if they call a bad spot.
On the flip side....as a very experienced pilot, a former jump pilot, and a very experienced jumper.....when the green light goes on, I assume the pilot expects we will make the DZ no problem. Of course, if you have a 10 way RW exiting a Twotter, and you give them the light 10-12 seconds before the spot to facilitate their exit, it's understandable......but when the green light comes on(on any load other than the first of the day), and the first group lands WAY out....there's apparently something wrong with the spot.
Most skydivers these days don't know how to properly check the spot....but whether or not they are able to make the DZ also depends on certain things, like the canopies they are flying. Do you take that into account, as a pilot? If you have a group of RW'ers that are all flying Manta 288's exit first, as opposed to a group of freeflyers flying Xaos 98's....the ability to make the DZ is vastly different for the two. No, of course you don't take that into account....you trust the jumpers to make that determination. Ultimately, it IS their responsibility, but as we've already determined....spotting is a lost art.
As far as I'm concerned, if you turn on the green light and somebody lands off(aside from a low pull or cutaway), it IS your fault. I took that responsibility as a pilot, but I also take that responsibility as a jumper. If
I land off,
I take full responsibility for it......but then again, I have a lot more experience than many of the jumpers, and I started jumping in a time when spotting was taught, but much easier(spotting for a C182 with 4 jumpers as opposed to a Twotter with 21 jumpers).
I know better than to exit before I can make the LZ(I am usually among the first group or two out, and am often the spotter for the load).
The really sad part is when an experienced jumper attempts to have a word with the pilot regarding the spot where they turn the green light on.....the pilot usually has a holier than thou attitude, and refuses to listen....unless they are also an experienced jumper.