Re: Pilotage, ded reckoning and E6-B v. GPS, RNAV, and state-of-the-art (?) avionics
bobbysamd said:
It is not an old and tired argument at all. In fact, with all the high-tech equipment available these delays, knowing basic navigation is more relevant than ever.
Absolutely right. You'd be amazed at the number of times you hear conversations like this:
Pilot: "Uhhhh, So-Cal approach this is Bugsmasher 12345 VFR to Podunk, request VFR advisories."
So-Cal: "Bugsmasher 12345 say position"
Pilot: "Uhhh, I'm heading 327.3 degrees."
So-Cal: "No sir, where are you located right now?"
Pilot: "Uhhhhhh, I'm 163.2 miles from Podunk right now, I will arrive there in 1 hour 23 minutes and 18 seconds."
So-Cal: "Sir could you give me your location reference your nearest airport or navaid?"
Pilot: "Uhhhhhhhhhh....." (VERY long pause) "......I am 23.2 miles from the ABC VOR. It looks like ABC is on a 231.7 heading from where I am."
So-Cal: "Ok, 23 miles northeast of ABC. Squawk 1234 and say altitude."
Pilot: "Altitude 4500."
So-Cal: "Radar contact. Now I am having a hard time finding Podunk Airport. Could you give me the ID?"
Pilot (quickly responds): "KXYZ."
So-Cal: "OK thanks. Still not sure about where that is. Do you know what another closeby airport is in that area?"
Pilot: "Uhhhhhhh......"
This goes on and on. He knows where he took off from, he knows where he is going, he knows how far away it is to the tenth of a mile, he knows to the second when he will arrive there, he knows the heading he needs to fly right to the Nth degree, but he doesn't have the foggiest idea where he is, what he is close to, or what is near his destination. He probably has no idea how to read a chart, or use any of the other navaids in his airplane other than his GPS.
These type of conversations happen with alarming regularity. I think instructors are doing their students a disservice by not teaching them the fundamentals of basic navigation.
LAXSaabdude.