Many moons ago I had the opportunity to decided between ATA and AirTran (I went to ATA and Im very happy there), I put together a comparsion chart at that time, so here it is, both are great airlines with great people....good luck..
ATA vs. AirTran
ATA
Health – after 24mos completion of service the company will fund 100% for the cost of medical coverage. For employees under 24mos the company will fund 65% of medical. Company also pays for 2 FAA medical exams a year.
LTD-66 2/3% payment by company
401K- company matches .60 for every 1.00 up to 6% contribution. Ie based on 50k with max contribution = $1800 match. Also has “TRUE UP” matching plan for those that meet max contributions before year is over.
RETIREMENT- CMP plan (B – fund) Matches per Pilot Earnings (number are detailed for me)
2003-4% 2004-4.5% 2005-5.0% 2006-5.5% . the 12yr match in 2006 = 12%
COMPENSATION-1st year 36/hr till july then 37.50 - 2nd year 63.40/hr - 12yr capt 187.24
Monthly Guar – 75hours = 2700/2812 (july) also 12.50/hr CRAF override also $50 holiday pay.
UPGRADES– running 5 years
UNION- ALPA
AIRTRAN
Health-For the first year of employment, AirTran Airways contributes 50% toward the monthly cost. After the Crew Member's first anniversary, AirTran Airways contributes 60% towards the monthly cost.
LTD-66 2/3% payment by company
401K- No company match
RETIREMENT-company funded b-plan 10.5% starting 2003
COMPENSATION-Top capt pay is $152.57 at 12yrs on the 717.
1st year fo pay at AirTran is $39.50, $42.75 after 4/1/04.
2nd year pay is $53.49, $55.94 after 4/1/04
Monthly Guar – 70hours = 2765
UPGRADES –runnning 2-3 years
UNION- in house