You suggested they look elsewhere. Not negotiate for COLA.
And none of that has anything to do with basic work definitions that we would take a stand on too. The company seems to be taking air tran and international as an opportunity to have less full time employees on the ramp and a lot more contract employees.
Ever dealt with contract employees on a large scale??
It's stepping over dollars to save dimes, I promise.
While there very well may be less-obvious downsides to contract employees (your "stepping over dollars..." comment), there's a side to the rampers' contract that you seem to be missing. The company is not "taking AirTran and international as an opportunity" for more contact employees out of spite or anything, like the rampers seem to be suggesting. The rampers' union actually agreed to this several years ago.
Several contracts ago, their union agreed that in the future, for any city with less than so many daily flights (I think 6 or 8; I don't remember exactly), the company could use contract employees below the wing. Current (at that time) SWA cities were exempt, and would keep using company employees, regardless of the number of daily flights. In return, the union got slightly larger raises. In effect, the union "sold" some future work, in return for cash up front for current employees. It certainly seemed a little short-sighted, especially when you consider the importance of scope. Nevertheless, it's a little disingenuous for the rampers to bitch about it now, when the company wants to collect what it's been paying for for the last several years. Or at least for them to imply that the company's pulling "dirty tricks" by wanting to use contractors.
None of this has anything to do with payrates though, and I believe that their union is just as justified as our own in asking for
real COLA raises, plus some other small bennies in work rules/whatever to reward the employees for their parts in the company's recent large successes. But if they
also want back something that they previously sold away (scope), then they better be prepared to
buy it back. It's the same lesson that several pilots unions learned the hard way about their predecessors' actions.
Bubba