As far as I know, JIFP will not print terminal procedures, so if that's a consideration, go with Aeroplanner.
I used aeroplanner for a few checkrides and a few flights when I was training at Airman. I was always happy with the quality and the idea that not only could I plan and print using IFR charts, but also VFR sectional charts. That made it nice for the cross country for the Commercial checkride. Print, cut, staple, present to examiner and it went over very well.
I don't use either now, just Jeppesen's NavSuite which is FliteStar, JeppView and FliteDeck all in one. I like it because most of my flights are IFR, so printing the trip-tik (like AAA) for the flights is very convenient and I can do all of the terminal charts along the way as possible diversions.
Unfortunately, this laptop is junk right now and until I can get the motherboard replaced, I can't really use it "EFB-style" as I want to, but rather I carry the binders with me in case I need to divert someplace I hadn't printed.
I like it for a few reasons.
1. Perfectly legal for my pt 91 flights.
2. Convenient as all hell.
3. Easy revisions, I download from the internet. With aeroplanner or JIFP, you don't even need to do that.
4. Print what I want and don't have to worry about having all of the NDB approaches into podunk when I'm flying into ORD and only going to be on the ILS.
5. Integrates the weather right into the flight plan (I believe aeroplanner does this too) so the navlog is within a few minutes of actual.
You can't go wrong with either, though if you're looking for something to print terminal charts, I don't belive JIFP provides that for you. If you're just looking to have the enroutes and you'll be carrying paper TPPs, then either is fine.
IMHO
-mini
PS
Personally, for $90/month, NavSuite is well worth it.