One thing about the baseball/airline analogy. there is a big difference: airlines provide a commodity service ie there is little brand loyalty bc, for the most part, there is little differentiation between services provided by the airlines particularly among the majors and regionals. Look at it as reserving a rental car. Do you care who you rent from? No, you go to the one that is cheapest and most convienent. Baseball, however, has hometown teams, loyal support, etc and therefore people are willing to spend $50/ticket to see Mark McGuire. Its only airlines that differientiate themselves from the pack like JB (new airbus offering cheap fares and upbeat service), Midwest (premium onboard meals and service, chinaware, cookies, etc), and Airtran and SWA (rock-bottom prices/no-frills service) that stand away from being a commodity. Is it a shock that these are the airlines that are doing well (ok, Midwest isnt doing so well bc of there dependence on business travelers)?
The regionals are also a commodity. They all mainly fly the same type airplanes and could be substituted for each other with relatively little fanfare (repaint airplanes, change domiciles). That was held over our heads at ACA. "Mesa could replace us in 2-3 years as UAL phases us out and ramps up MESA." Therefore, as pilots, although we are highly skilled and trained labor, we are also expendable and interchangeable, and therefore a commodity too. Doctors and lawyers arent so easily interchangeable. Ask a cardiologist to do brain surgery. Ask a real estate lawyer to be defense counsel in a murder case. Ask a CRJ Capt to become a Airbus FO, thats doable. Do you see my point?
best wishes, fly safe