Legacies have orders on the books to replace about half of their domestic narrow body fleets, so it might seem that their solution to the pilot shortage is to shrink. Someone going to a legacy now might just be jumping onto the bottom of a shrinking list. Fine if you are in your twenties or early thirties, otherwise not so great.
Scope clauses are great, until the next bankruptcy which seems to be part of the airline business model.
The future will not look like the past; regionals boomed over the last decade and there has already been a lot of consolidation, a few more will probably disappear over the next few years.
So long as oil remains expensive and the economy stagnant, it's nong to be good for anyone.
How many pilots were employed by legacies in 1999, how many now? The glory days of buying a new Caddy with a single paycheck are gone forever and a pilot shortage won't change that. Your pay is limited by the revenue you generate and this is the age of Priceline. Consumers just wan't a cheep ticket.
My wife just bought three tickets on Delta PDX to PHL, this summer through Priceline, while sorting out a lost bag situation we learned that Delta netted only $60 on each ticket. Sixty bucks round trip, cross country, in the summer. If you want to make big bucks, don't be a pilot.