Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

Oberstar won't back DL/NWA merger....article

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web

General Lee

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2002
Posts
20,442
Lawmaker won't back Northwest-Delta merger; 1h 3m ago USA TODAY


U.S. House Transportation Committee Chairman James Oberstar said Wednesday that he opposes ongoing merger talks between Minnesota-based Northwest Airlines and Delta Air Lines, saying any merger of major domestic carriers would hurt consumers.
Oberstar, a Minnesota Democrat and a key player in aviation policy, said any airline consolidation would result in a rapid collapse of the industry into two or three megacarriers. "I don't think mergers are in the best public interest, and that includes this one," he said.
Oberstar's comments came during a conference call with reporters in which he confirmed ongoing discussions between executives of Atlanta-based Delta (DAL), the USA's No. 3 airline, and No. 6 Northwest (NWA).
Neither Delta nor Northwest have publicly acknowledged the merger talks, and both declined to comment Wednesday.
Oberstar told reporters he invited Northwest executives to his office on Tuesday to discuss the status of merger talks to avoid operating "on the basis of rumor."

He said the executives confirmed the talks with Delta. The talks are in the early stages, Oberstar said, and the executives told him that they would look for another partner if Delta were to move ahead with No. 2 United Airlines (UAUA) as a merger partner instead of Northwest. Oberstar says he believes Northwest is currently talking only with Delta about a possible merger.
By law, mergers between large airlines must undergo scrutiny by the Department of Justice antitrust unit and the Department of Transportation. But congressional leaders can hold public hearings and exert pressure on regulators and have done so in the past.
Officials at American (AMR), currently the world's largest airline, said Wednesday that a "more rational industry structure" resulting from consolidation could benefit both consumers and the industry. But they stopped short of climbing onto the merger bandwagon.
CFO Tom Horton, in a conference call about American's quarterly financial performance, said the complexity of putting together two airlines makes it difficult to achieve the desired results. Horton said American is watching Delta's search for a possible merger partner closely and contemplating what its competitive response, if any, would be, he said.
U.S. Rep. Jerry Costello, a Democrat from United's headquarters state of Illinois and chairman of the House aviation subcommittee, issued a statement saying, "The history of these (merger) deals is not a positive one for consumers and airline employees." At the same time, Costello said, he'd review any proposed merger on its merits.
Contributing: Dan Reed and Marilyn Adams



Bye Bye--General Lee
 
Last edited:
A little "campaign donation" can fix that problem.
 
None of the lawmakers are going to endorse a merger when loss of jobs are imminent, especially now during an election year. They will publicly denounce it while the DOJ does the approval.

You have to admit though, fundamentally, why would congress ever want a merger to happen. The carriers appear to be doing ok (not great, but ok), there is PLENTY of competion and ticket prices are extremely low. What will mergers do? Remove excess capacity and raise prices? The big problem is the fact that the government needs to get their fingers out of the "airline industry" cookie jar. Let carriers go out of business, let the employees strike, etc. If not, either re-regulate or provide fuel subsidies to the airlines. Oh, and use the aviation and airline taxes to update our ATC system.
 
I find it amusing that so many diehard ALPA folks continue to support the liberal agenda of "protecting the consumer".......

The first step to negotiating higher pay is to return the airline's to sustainable profitability.... Worrying about the "poor consumer" is not my concern....They are already getting a heck of a deal that isn't keeping up with inflation..... Let the airlines get together and raise prices..... That is what we need......
 
Let the airlines get together and raise prices......


In case you didn't know, that is illegal. Also, it doesn't work because there is always one person/group that will cheat in order to get more. But then, I am sure you knew that.
 
In case you didn't know, that is illegal. Also, it doesn't work because there is always one person/group that will cheat in order to get more. But then, I am sure you knew that.

..... I know it is illegal.... The liberal politicians are looking out for the "poor consumer".......

The current system doesn't allow for price raising, and it is hurting everyone.....

I don't understand why so many union folks support the liberal politicians who make things hard for business.....

We can't negotiate for more if our companies don't make money...... Support Pro Business politicians....

Our ability to negotiate depends on our companies making money..... We aren't Govt. employees who can negotiate for more when losing money......
 
..... I know it is illegal.... The liberal politicians are looking out for the "poor consumer".......

The current system doesn't allow for price raising, and it is hurting everyone.....

I don't understand why so many union folks support the liberal politicians who make things hard for business.....

We can't negotiate for more if our companies don't make money...... Support Pro Business politicians....

Our ability to negotiate depends on our companies making money..... We aren't Govt. employees who can negotiate for more when losing money......

Yeah, those conservatives we've had in office for the last 8 years are doing wonders for the economy, and the American worker.

What rock have you been living under?
 
Please, Joe. You don't really believe what you are typing here do you. It has nothing to do with Liberal vs. Conservative. Your form of an Oligopoly just wont work becuase someone is always willing to charge a lower price.

In your idealistic airline market, where should the price be set?
 
Yeah, those conservatives we've had in office for the last 8 years are doing wonders for the economy, and the American worker.

What rock have you been living under?

What is Hillary going to do to make things better for me..... Be specific now......

I look to the Private Sector to help me out.....not to Wash. DC.......

Specifics now, what are the solutions from the other side of the aisle.....
 
Please, Joe. You don't really believe what you are typing here do you. It has nothing to do with Liberal vs. Conservative. Your form of an Oligopoly just wont work becuase someone is always willing to charge a lower price.

In your idealistic airline market, where should the price be set?

So then it wouldn't matter if the airlines were allowed to get together to set prices...... After all, according to YOU, someone would charge a lower price anyway....

So why not allow the airlines to get together and set prices......
 
Oberstar can claim whatever he wants, he is gone soon. Oberstar is a mope politician, Delta and NWA corporate legal teams will ram-rod this

wonder what the new call sign will be

Delta-West

NorthDelta

Merger

???
 
Oberstar can claim whatever he wants, he is gone soon. Oberstar is a mope politician, Delta and NWA corporate legal teams will ram-rod this

wonder what the new call sign will be

Delta-West

NorthDelta

Merger

???

When will he be out? This year? The airlines wanted to merge quickly before the next administration comes in and changes things around. He is incharge of the Aviation Sub Comittee and he wrote a paper on why Airlines should NOT merge when United and USAir tried to do it back then, when he was just a member of the comittee. Now he is the Chairman of that same comittee.

Bye Bye--General Lee
 
So then it wouldn't matter if the airlines were allowed to get together to set prices...... After all, according to YOU, someone would charge a lower price anyway....

So why not allow the airlines to get together and set prices......

Because we are a capitalistic nation and oligopoly's work to restrict the supply of resources in the free market.

Back to my question now, what should the price of an airline ticket be?
 
None of the lawmakers are going to endorse a merger when loss of jobs are imminent, especially now during an election year. They will publicly denounce it while the DOJ does the approval.

You have to admit though, fundamentally, why would congress ever want a merger to happen. The carriers appear to be doing ok (not great, but ok), there is PLENTY of competion and ticket prices are extremely low. What will mergers do? Remove excess capacity and raise prices? The big problem is the fact that the government needs to get their fingers out of the "airline industry" cookie jar. Let carriers go out of business, let the employees strike, etc. If not, either re-regulate or provide fuel subsidies to the airlines. Oh, and use the aviation and airline taxes to update our ATC system.

Amen. Amen. Amen.
 

Latest resources

Back
Top Bottom