Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

ASA Strike?

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web

ex j-41

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 25, 2005
Posts
881
4 years without a contract...Why can't ASA pilots strike?

It's the only way to get management to listen.
 
Um.....in case you haven't been paying attention, pilots don't get to just decide to strike. They are governed by the Railway Labor Act, and Federal Mediators (NMB) decide when and if a union can strike. While we at ASA think you have a great idea there, our hands are tied by the process.
 
you are missing the question...I was asking why you cannot strike? What in the railway labor act is stopping you?
 
Before a strike, the RLA requires a 30 day cooling off period, usually accompanied by super-mediated negotiations. Once the 30 days comes and goes, if no agreement has been reached, either party may take action against the other. The union may strike, the company can lock out their employees. The NMB refuses to release us into the 30 day cooling off perion, thus draaaaaaging out the negotiation process. They are seemingly so anti-labor friendly they see fit to only schedule us for 1 or 2 days of negotiations every two or three months! Hard to get an agreement done that way.

Hope you see the picture.
 
Well checking my e-mail this morning and seeing the ALPA newletter regarding your situation caught my attention. I assume that this was the intention. Sounds to me that the lawyers are winning this war. I just hope that we the labor in this country can vote in a pro labor goverment.
 
Before a strike, the RLA requires a 30 day cooling off period, usually accompanied by super-mediated negotiations. Once the 30 days comes and goes, if no agreement has been reached, either party may take action against the other. The union may strike, the company can lock out their employees. The NMB refuses to release us into the 30 day cooling off perion, thus draaaaaaging out the negotiation process. They are seemingly so anti-labor friendly they see fit to only schedule us for 1 or 2 days of negotiations every two or three months! Hard to get an agreement done that way.

Hope you see the picture.

Before a cooling off period begins, the NMB has to declare an impasse in negotiations. When they do that, they offer us (or proffer) arbitration. If either party declines arbitration, then the cooling off period begins.
 
As long as Bush is President, there will be no release. Remember that the President is the one who appoints the mediators. They are all anti labor, so the Union will never get the upper hand.
 
Ah yes, Democrats will solve all of our problems. When Hillary gets in office she will replace the NMB with her people and labor will rise to a new glorious position. Then they, Hiilary and company, will take it back thru higher taxes (ie. letting the recent tax cuts expire and instigating new ones).


Goat
 
As long as Bush is President, there will be no release. Remember that the President is the one who appoints the mediators. They are all anti labor, so the Union will never get the upper hand.

Wrong.

Strikes:
2006 - Petroleum Helicopters (PHI Inc)
2006 - World Airways
2005 - Polar Air Cargo
2005 -Northwest Airlines (mechanics)
2001 - Comair

All of those happened under Bush.
 
ah yes, vote in Hilary so we can all walk down the primrose path together, singing kumbaya. what a glorious world it will be....


....or not
 
If you guys think GW's tax cuts actually reach to our levels, you've been sniffing the Jet-A. Those tax cuts go to the Jonathan Orensteins and Paul Foleys of the world, not us. And BTW, they're laughing their a** off at us, because WE'RE paying for THEIR tax cut.

Enjoy.
 
I just read a comment Warren Buffet made how he paid 17% in taxes (on $46,000,000) while his secretary who made 65k paid almost 30%.
 
Wrong.

Strikes:
2006 - Petroleum Helicopters (PHI Inc)
2006 - World Airways
2005 - Polar Air Cargo
2005 -Northwest Airlines (mechanics)
2001 - Comair

All of those happened under Bush.


The Comair strike happened as a carry over from Clinton. If Comair had Bush mediators , they would still be in NMB hell right now right along with ASA. OH , I forgot to add, yes there will be releases, but only when the company has enough scabs to replace you. Why don't you do a google check and see how well those NW mechs are doing right now. Has Bush set up a PEB to help resolve anything? WHy don't you read Flying the Line Vol 2, or Hard Landing. Two books that will teach you about some really great Republicans like Frank Lorenzo, Dick Ferris, and Bob Crandall.
 
Um.....in case you haven't been paying attention, pilots don't get to just decide to strike. They are governed by the Railway Labor Act, and Federal Mediators (NMB) decide when and if a union can strike. While we at ASA think you have a great idea there, our hands are tied by the process.

But pilots can decide to semi-strike and get this thing done. With all of the jobs available right now, I don't understand why this pilot group will not rock the boat! Jerry and Bryan are loving this group; all bark and no bite. Until something is done on the line, nothing is going to happen in negotiations. What incentive does management have to settle? Absolutely none!
 
If you guys think GW's tax cuts actually reach to our levels, you've been sniffing the Jet-A. Those tax cuts go to the Jonathan Orensteins and Paul Foleys of the world, not us. And BTW, they're laughing their a** off at us, because WE'RE paying for THEIR tax cut.

Enjoy.
I don't know about you, but I enjoyed a tax savings starting in 2002 by removing the marriage penalty. I also enjoyed a savings by the lowering of all tax rates.

Note also that no one "pays" for a tax cut. If that were the case then taxes would have to be raised on another income group or source of income, and that hasn't happened. Starting in 2001 through 2007, everyone got a tax cut of about 2%-3% except for the lowest income bracket which received a cut of 5% with the addition of a new lower tax braket.

As far as Warren Buffett (however you spell it), he doesn't exactly get paid in the form of a paycheck and doesn't get his taxes withheld. Also, he rails on how the "rich" don't need a tax cut, but he manages vis-a-vis his accountants to find every tax loophole and shelter available to keep him from paying "his fair share" of taxes, as is his right within the law. I would bet that if you actually looked at his return, you would see that he paid 35% on his taxable income.
 
OH , I forgot to add, yes there will be releases, but only when the company has enough scabs to replace you. Why don't you do a google check and see how well those NW mechs are doing right now.


Where exactly are you gonna find and train 1700 SCAB RJ pilots? Nobody can find pilots right now at airlines that aren't in the turmoil that ASA is in.
 
I just read a comment Warren Buffet made how he paid 17% in taxes (on $46,000,000) while his secretary who made 65k paid almost 30%.

If Warren Buffet doesn't think he is paying enough tax, he is free to pay more. He can send the IRS 90% of his income and they won't send it back. If he's not willing to do that, he should STFU.
 
INote also that no one "pays" for a tax cut

Your kids will considering the inability of the government (all branches, all parties) to only spend the money they actually have instead of turning a record surplus into a record deficit. The bill's gonna come due eventually.
 
question?

Just a question from an outsider looking in. Would an ASA strike even hurt Delta as the Comair strike did in 01'? Does ASA have much leverage left in its route structure, with all the other regionals flying feed into ATL? Are there routes that are truly ASA's or has Delta crossfilled the scheldule so that no single carrier can cripple them. What is Skywest's plan for ASA,,,,Did they just want the planes and relationship with Delta? Do they even care about ASA personell? Just curious, being from Atlanta, I hope everything works out for you guys.
 
ASA has over 900 flights a day, you tell me?

701EV
 
Just wait until the evening of Aug 31st if nothing is accomplished from the 4 days. Pilots have had enough, and ASA will experience the ghosts of '98!

Name the date. I'll be with you. It is too hot to fish so I'll just say home and spend time with the family, maybe drink some beer.
 
ASA has over 900 flights a day, you tell me?

701EV


What i think....I think Chautauqua will take pilots off the US Air system and use them to fly for Delta. Maybe Mesa will do the same. Either way unless our Union "S" protect us all, we are doomed!
 
But pilots can decide to semi-strike and get this thing done. With all of the jobs available right now, I don't understand why this pilot group will not rock the boat! Jerry and Bryan are loving this group; all bark and no bite. Until something is done on the line, nothing is going to happen in negotiations. What incentive does management have to settle? Absolutely none!

Most of us would rather just take what is on the table and move on.
 
What i think....I think Chautauqua will take pilots off the US Air system and use them to fly for Delta. Maybe Mesa will do the same. Either way unless our Union "S" protect us all, we are doomed!

Before a strike, the ASA MEC will pass a resolution that defines "struck work." Typically, if another carrier already flies the same routes that the striking carrier does, then any increase in the number of frequencies or the size of the aircraft would meet the definition of struck work. So, if Mesa currently only flies one flight on a route that ASA does 5 flights, then if Mesa were to start flying 3 flights after the start of the strike, that would be considered struck work. This happened back in '04 at PCL/MSA when the MSA pilots were about to go on strike. We flew many of the same routes, but the MSA MEC defined struck work as any increase in flying on those routes. So, the PCL MEC made it clear that we would not be flying any struck work. If the IBT reps at CHQ have any common sense, they'll do the same in the event of an ASA strike.
 
Your kids will considering the inability of the government (all branches, all parties) to only spend the money they actually have instead of turning a record surplus into a record deficit. The bill's gonna come due eventually.

The government has enough tax revenue. The problem is the Congress loves to earmark all of it away for garbage like the war on poverty. Then they cut Medicare so far back that doctors are refusing to accept it. This is just the case Hillary needs to turn the already ailing medical sector into a heaping train wreck so she can get elected by people who don't want to work and want the government to take care of them. You gotta love politics right now. Unfortunately all sides are to blame, but the Democrats are the worst of the worst. And neither side is going to "help" airline pilots. The Dems think we make too much money, and the Republicans do to. At least the Republicans will let you keep more of what you can manage to negotiate.
 
Last edited:

Latest resources

Back
Top Bottom