movingviolation said:
Because the entry level chevy is about ten grand less than the entry level audi.
I hope you're not really trying to tell me that there is any comparison at ALL between a Cavalier and an A4... If you want to limit it to drag racing, fine. That's your prerogative. If that's your only gauge of the relative worth of two cars, I can't add anything to this discussion. I'll just say this: There's a reason that the A4 is ten grand more than the Chevy, and it's got nothing to do with what flashes on the screen at the end of a 1320-foot race.
As for cars melting on the racetrack, you won't find me quibbling with you that the M3 is a better track car than the S4. This is exactly as the respective manufacturers intended, of course. The M3 is a track car ALL the time, very stiff, very loud, and very rambunctious (much more so than the prior two models of M3, both of which I have street and autocross experience with). The S4 is geared more towards the street and suffers on the track as a consequence.
While these cars theoretically compete in the marketplace, they will attract two different buyers. Typically the M3 will go to the person who is buying a very expensive toy that is less suited for the street but doesn't need it as their only car, and the S4 will go to the person who wants almost all that performance, plus the ability to engage in the more mundane pursuits of grocery-getting and driving to work without knocking out all your fillings. Not to mention what happens when snow or rain enter the picture... I drove an M3 in the snow, or rather should I say it drove ME?... I had a lot more fun in a plain-vanilla A4, because my version of "fun" doesn't involve wondering if I will make it up the hill at night when the roads are covered with snow.
The people who can afford either one of these cars have an enviable choice, to be sure, but I bet in reality there isn't much cross-shopping. I would also point out that the S4 is the only car to ever beat the M3 (of any vintage) in a comparison test in the pages of Car and Driver magazine, which IMHO is the best car rag in the States, if not the world... And the S4 did it TWICE, once with the old 2.7TT engine and again with the newer V8. This is borderline amazing considering the thirty-year love affair C&D has had with BMW. I don't remember for sure, but I think Road and Track came to the same conclusion when comparing the S4, M3 and one of those supercharged M-B AMG's, but I'm not certain.
And no, I don't own stock in Audi.
