Lowering the minimums is NOT mandatory....not by a long shot. Pinnacle has hired off the street captains before and can do it again. Just hope they screen those fellas a little better. That first group had some pretty arrogant jacka..es.
BINGO!
And your memory isn't entirely accurate about the first couple street CA classes in 2001. The company made sure they hired the best that was out there, guys with no issues, previous checkride problems, good HR backgrounds, then threw them into a training department that was, quite possibly, the worse I've ever seen.
The systems instructor wasn't a pilot. He was an ex-military grunt who wanted you to think was an Army Ranger "Caused he JUMPED off of TANKS and HELICOPTERS and KILLED PEOPLE DEAD!" (you had to be there to hear that little rant, it made the class SO much more fun to be able to razz on this guy.
This instructor had absolutely ZERO teaching ability or background. He had been pulled from being a baggage boy into the CEC and watched 2 initial classes go through, was handed the slides, and said "Go for it."
Nothing more irritating than to have to have your OWN class AFTER class is over for the day. And we did. Had 3 or 4 new-hire F/O's who had never flown a jet study with us in the hotel lounge at least 3 times per week to help them unlearn the crap he'd filled their head with.
Now if that makes us "Pretty arrogant jackasses" to put our foot down and say, "I know just enough to be able to say that is COMPLETE bull******************** and is not how the system works". Some people were more political, but at some point you gotta tell the guy he's just wrong or other people suffer - that whole law of primacy thing for learning going on.
However, the street CA plan, for the most part, worked out well for Corporate, and I'd be very surprised to see them go directly to lowering minimums before seeing what they could find in the available street CA pool first.
It happened that way 3 times while I was there, it'll probably happen again.