Herman Bloom said:
Pilots who yell about management are by and large class warriors. And like all class warriors, they would JUMP at the *hypothetical* opportunity to assume an upper management position if the price was right.
That is a generalization....and as you know, all generalizations are false...including this one.
I don't think "
class warfare" is the driver.
I think we're wired a little differently, and it has nothing to do with caste. Pilots are skeptics. We are in control, and taught from day-one to be distrustful of anyone but ourselves. The weather briefer says VFR at CLE?...Ha! I'm
still loading the extra gas. ATC says no other traffic in the pattern?...I'm
still checking final as I turn base. We are even taught not to trust ourselves! (Is the gear down?...I'm using a checklist!)
We do our jobs with a remarkable rate of success. When we are unsuccessful....it's the lead story on the nightly news, nationwide. Our habitual success is a source of pride to us. (So is the danger of the unsucessfaul part)
When someone who doesn't have to schlep his bags through the slush to the crew bus...double-dip through de-icing...then sleep in the EWR-short hotel (overlooking the prison; right next to the "
Don't Pick Up Hitchhikers!" sign), treats us like a "cost item", it breeds resentment.
Pillows....$2
Fuel.......$1.65
Pilot.......$130
Another source of resentment is the lack of respect. No little kid ever walked down the street...heard a noise...and looked up at the 34th floor a building, thinking "
Someday I hope I'm in a cubicle up there doing quarterly reports!"
But there were plenty of us who heard the airplanes, and always stopped and looked.
Always.
We respect this profession because it is an honorable one, and we take pride in doing it. Those who would diminish it's luster (if only to us) are insulting us. It's hard not to take it personally when "managers" refuse to acknowledge us as keen decision-makers too.
Yip is absolutely correct: these are the best managers money can buy, and pilots are readily replaceable. Why is this such a shock to some of you?
1. Because they act like "managers". If they acted like "
leaders" we'd follow them!
2. Because we are used to being successful in our jobs, regardless of the environment.
3. Because every pilot, regardless of how good they really are, thinks they're "above average". They expect the managers to be above average too! (From a statistical standpoint...every manager cannot be "above average". Even managers in Lake Woebegon. Ditto pilots)
4. Because managers don't stick around! They come in, make their loot, pull the ripcord, and ride the Golden Parachute...while the rest of us ride the aircraft in. I'm on my 5th CEO. The 1st 4 are being paid by my "struggling major airline based in the upper-Midwest" even though they are doing nothing.