Gunfyter hit the nail on the head. For me, leaving or staying at NJA will be a business decision, not a personal one.
I am in an interesting position.....I'm currently at NJA, but am in the hiring pool at UPS. I applied to UPS a long time ago, and never heard anything, so I thought I'd try NJA. I was hired quickly, went through training, and really like the company. Fast forward a year later.....UPS calls, I interview, and am placed in their hiring pool. Am I going to tell UPS "no thanks" when they give me a class date? I don't think so. If I had HBA, and the pay was better at NJA, would I be thinking twice about leaving? You bet I would. Did I take the job at NJA to get a free type rating and then exit stage left? You've got to be kidding me.
The reality of the airline business (because it is so competitive) is that a smart pilot will apply to everybody, and take the first decent offer that is placed in his lap. You're not going to apply to an airline one at a time, and either get hired/turned down, and then apply to the next one. That would take forever, and it just isn't realistic.
As Michael Corleone says in The Godfather, "It's not personal Sonny, it's strictly business."
Archie,
From what I have read on your posts on this web site you are stand up guy. If UPS calls I would go, if I was in your shoes. No one is going to hold it against you. Maybe a bunch of you guys leaving will be the catalyst for everyone getting HBA. God knows their Domicle plan is a bunch of BS and isn't saving the company any money. It is drving a wedge between the pilots though.