I liked the hat, the general public likes us in hats, but they sure can be a bother, especially to those commuting to work.
In the Marines, we all wore our hats, because it was required, and because it was not optional. We also had a lot of pride in our uniforms and appearance, and the uniform is an expression of our professionalism and attitude. We don't care what the public thinks, as long as they and our enemies respect us.
Fashion and comfort had absolutely nothing to do with it. You were a Marine, so you wore your cover, obeyed orders, and accomplished your mission. No doubts in anyone's eyes, friend or foe.
Applying this to pilots, airlines, and alpa is tough. They all have had a hand in degrading our profession and standards. The hat problem is merely a symptom of the bigger problem. The UAL "hat switch"? Juvenile and immature....
If our profession/industry was squared away, there would be no hat issue. Unions and management would take a stand, either way....
---Outsource!!, the rallying cry of managers and greedy senior Captains.....