Skippy,
It's a wonderful sentiment, but it lacks a business plan.
I live near a small local airport, I work there part-time, I park my airplane there, I buy gas there when the price is cheaper than the competion nearby.
I got my Private, Instr, Commercial and Multi at a "local" FBO. But then, I wanted my CFI ratings - all of them. Started seeing the ads for the "factories" as you call them. So I went to the local Chief CFI and said here's what I want to do - get my CFI, II and MEI between now (August) and December. After much hemming and hawing, I got the following answers:
1.) We don't have a CFI right now who is qualified to sign off other CFI's and I'm too busy.
2.) The weather is going to get terrible.
3.) The guy at FSDO doesn't "like" me.
4.) I can't guarantee that schedule.
So I went to COMAIR in Orlando. For $9,000 which I would have gladly spent with my local FBO, I got:
1.) A curriculum and schedule that included all the ground school, simulators, flight training and even predicted phase checks and test dates.
2.) Three dedicated CFI's for each of the three tickets.
3.) A guarantee that if I held my end of the bargain and studied hard and kept with phase checks that I would leave in 60 days with the tickets in hand for the price paid.
4.) Dependable weather and aircraft.
The "factory" in this case delivered. Sure there are complaints about the cost and the rigid contracts, etc. but I and a number of other folks are getting what they pay for. A lot of the FBO's and especially those in the North East can be down right frustrating with schedules, weather, CFI turnover, small aircraft fleet, etc. It just hurts when you have a motivated student with the means to afford a certain quality level and the local business can't deliver.
I would hate to see my local airport close - but I can't suddenly wave a magic wand and make laws of economics disappear. Customers will seek the product they want at the price they want. A lot of folks in aviation don't understand that concept.
MY local airport is business stupid when they should be business saavy. They have an overpriced product but they deliver it like we live in some farm district rather than in a Mid-Atlantic suburban setting. People are pulling up in Lexus and Audis looking for flying lessons and we are delivering 1975 airplanes operated out of a 40 year old building that hasn't had a paint job or new furniture in the same period.
Contrast that to two FBO's in different directions down the interstate. One is on a grass field, operating out of an old farm house and charges rock bottom prices for everything from gas to GPS units. Business is booming. The other direction has an FBO with 7 new Cessna airplanes, fresh from the factory. New paint, new showrooms. $125/hr for the plane, $40/hour for instruction. Business is booming there too.
Of the three airports, we deliver the best physical location to the major metro area.
So I will support lots of local airports, but the bell is ringing for a lot of these airports to get smart, to get lean, and to start attracting attention. I want bang for the buck! You just can't charge me an arm and a leg because you exist. I want a product that meets my needs at a price I can afford. Its financial management 101 - supply and demand - you can't force the issue.