Well this is a difficult question to answer as every company has it's own agenda and hiring criteria...
Does the guy with the "Lots of PIC Time" have that time in jets or is it all in pistons? Does the guy with the SIC time in Type have a reasonable amoount of PIC time, or is he a 2,500 TT with only 300 PIC total? There are many factors....
TYPICALLY operators perfer time in type.... But that is a generalization... When I got hired at my current job, they were flying Citation III's, I had never set foot inside a Citation, but they still hired me because I had a lot of Turbo-Jet background and PIC time (Lear, Falcon 10, Falcon 20).... I'm sure they had resumes from guys with Citation III time.... There is just a lot of factors....
How this helps....
Good Luck and Fly Safe!