Tough Decision!
Hey Pugshots:
First off, congratulations on having 3 job offers and a choice to make...that's a nice position to be in. Additionally, the fact that you are single gives you another advantage: you can easily move to the base that you will fly from. The previous poster mentioned having to spend "30% of your time on days off commuting" but this is a choice you make. I've always found that pilots who commute are almost without exception less happy with their jobs than pilots who live in their bases. Skyway looks good right now although there will certainly be a period of major instability as the Delta Connection plan gets up to speed. If everything happens as planned you would have the choice to live in MKE or CVG, both decent places with reasonable costs of living. You would gain seniority quickly and have the option of upgrading quickly or staying as an FO for better schedules. If you choose Skyway try to avoid the 1900 like the plauge. The 1900 fleet is usually understaffed and the combination of poor aircraft utilization and typically short flights translates into very bad schedules that never seem to get better. One word of warning: Skyway is hiring for the "planned" expansion but their is a risk that the Delta Connection deal will never happen and mass layoffs would occur. The deal has yet to be finalized or announced publically and Delta may end up in Bankruptcy court which could cause them to reject the leases on the Do-328Jets and abandon that portion of the Delta Connection system; obviously leaving Skyway hanging in the wind.
PSA seems to be growing, but there are obviously risks here as well. They are owned by Usairways and the future of the entire USAirways Group is very uncertain....things don't look good for them. I could be wrong here and I don't work at PSA but I would think that the morale has to be pretty bad there and I wouldn't think it would be a very nice place to work at, but again, I'm just guessing.
I don't know much about Eagle but they are huge and I would think that they will be a survivor. AMR may be one of the big beneficiaries if USAirways and UAL pull back service or, God forbid, cease to exist entirely. Eagle may not grow quickly but they should be the most stable of the 3 airlines for the long haul.
Good luck with your decision, in the end you will have to make it on your own. When you talk about "QOL" you need to decide what that means to you because it means different things to different people. I hope you get some good advice from this forum but beware: pessimism, negativity and cynisicm runs rampant on these message boards. This industry has gone through some very tough times and there are a lot of very unhappy pilots out there. It's not an easy career path and being junior at a regional airline is never easy. I wish you the best with your career, and whatever decision you make don't look back later and second-guess yourself; nobody can see into the future of this industry.