mar said:
Yeah, you know what? It's over. Let it go Tony.
You can't possibly do any good by stirring this crap up over and over.
It doesn't (didn't) involve you and besides that, there can never be scabs without a strike.
Move on.
What's over? Did the 49ers get their jobs back? Tell their families it's over.
I was not attempting to stir anything - - I was trying to correct a few things CSY Mon got wrong. Also, I politely asked, as I have on previous threads, about the disposition of the 49ers - - nobody seems inclined to answer.
As long as I'm a part of the aviation industry, it affects me. And, Yes, there can be scabs without a strike. We've been over that before - - we disagree.
mar said:
I've been around and around with TonyC about the so called 'scab' thing.
Best wishes. I think CX is a fantastic company and would've been proud to work there.
Actually, if I recall the conversation correctly, I inquired how you knew so much about the Cathay interview process - - I didn't realized you had applied during the ban. Once you informed me of the details and we exchanged opinions, I dropped the subject out of a personal respect for you. We each knew where the other stood, but we drug it out no longer.
I will not, however, take an oath of eternal silence on the issue. When the subject comes up, I will participate. As I said, nobody seems proud to explain the disposition of the 49ers.
I tried to find the exact thread where we exchanged ideas about Cathay and scabbing, but came up short. (Perhaps it was through PMs that we conversed.) What I DID find during my search, however, is quite disturbing. Your foreknowledge of the hiring ban at Cathay did not discourage you from interviewing, you would have taken a job during the hiring ban if offered, you failed to see the logic of a hiring ban - - hiring SOs wouldn't be replacing Captains- - and you think it would be OK to scab if you don't support the union's decision to strike. I find those views repugnant.
We have not gone 'round and 'round by any stretch of the imagination, and I doubt that such an engagement would prove fruitful. I can understand why you would be very sensitive about the issue; you can at the very least give me the same level of respect for the principles which I support.