First of all, NWA owns most of the planes at Pinnacle and Mesaba. The pilots at XJ have no control over what aircraft they fly, but they have absolute control over who will fly them. Seniority at NWA is in no way connected to seniority at Mesaba or Pinnacle. Just because NWA may own the aircraft, that doesn't have any connection to the pilots at NWA having the right to fly them. If that was reality, current fuloughed NWA guys/gals would be flying Saabs and CRJ's right now.
Second, JFJ only works when there is a position to go back to at mainline. NWA in it's height of growth only hired 30 a month. With the 9's going away, NWA stands to lose 2000 pilot jobs. If you factor in record call backs, it would take over 5 years to rehire those pilots back. All of this is predicated on the fact that more flying won't be outsourced, which we know isn't the truth.
Everyone knows that the airline industry is cyclical. Do you really think there will be a five year hiring frenzy? Now factor in the difference in payrates between the Saab and the 70 seat CRJ. Take that 30 thousand difference and times that by 5. Does anyone in there right mind expect a pilot to give up 150,000 dollars of their money to take one for the team? Now your going to say they will have a number with mainline when everything pans out, which wouldn't work for one huge obvious reason. Pinnacle and Champion, and Mesaba would all have to flow up in some convaluted order.
So bottom line is that Pinnacle hired furloughed NWA pilots into the right seat, and XJ would be asked to hire them into the left, but both would share equally in a flow through.
If you are number 150 or higher at XJ, Pinnacle, or Champion, this might work out for you in the long run. But for the rest of the pilots below these seniority numbers, there would be no benefit at all to play the JFJ game. None.
Corporate ownership of an aircraft means nothing. XJ pilots will fly aircraft at XJ, Pinnacle pilots will fly aircraft at Pinnacle, and NWA pilots will fly aircraft at NWA.
-Spartacus