Relax! I've been here a long time and know we have better advocates now than at any time since I've been here.
Advocates? Seriously, are you saying the CP's are an advocate for pilots? Sorry, but they are not your advocate. A better analogy would be that they are, maybe, Referee's, but that really is not a fit definition, either. They are really Company representatives, and their job is to administer policy and supervise, but more importantly to protect the Company first. And, for me, that's OK, but, I know they are not my advocate. From time to time, they can be your facilitator. But, they are given the company and legal authority, they can be your Disciplinarian/Terminator or an agent therof. Someone who can discipline or terminate you or be ordered to discipline or terminate, is not your advocate--herein lies the conflict of interest.
When I said rules, I meant the contract, and in my case they've interpretted it without an agenda for either side. I know the rules, and it's good to know that when there is an issue I don't have to start by trying to figure out what "is" is.
The CP's are not contract experts. If you need an interpretation on something you are unsure of, contact the pilots or lawyer who negotiated it, or the ACC. Reading the contract and having general knowledge is a good thing, but many times it means nothing until there is an actual situation that it may apply. Unfortunately, as pilots or CP's, we can read the language, but may not know or understand the intent. That "is" the fact.
It's nice to have CPs who don't have you on the speaker phone in front of all their friends when they talk to you about something.