I don't doubt that this acquisition holds much potential. But to say that there is already empirical evidence of betterment is probably premature. And yes, Mr. Kelly is touting the positives, to be sure, but would we expect anything else? He is not one to report any of the negative bullet points in his hotline, or anywhere publicly.
I assume you mean outside of the considerable debt, outside of the difficulties and expenses in assimilating two different operations, outside of the difficulties in merging the union groups of two different companies, etc. Not saying there aren't many potential positives, but it is an extreme oversimplification to make the claim you just did.
You make a good point, but please don't think that most folks here are unaware or uncaring about the big picture of betterment for Southwest Airlines from this deal. Just remember that the long-term good from the acquisition will not be seen for many moons, and in fact is yet to even be a certain reality. Not every acquisition ends up being a great deal.
As for the personal reactions of the pilots, any negativity you see is only a fear of immediately detrimental slowdown of career progression, something that folks here have already been dealt twice (from retirement age changes, and from economic slowdown).
Actually, I think you'll be pleasantly surprised that you will be accepted on property with quite a bit of genuine welcome. Where you might see some vitriol in regards to attitudes directed at AAI guys might be in th case that a former AAI guy shows a lousy attitude regarding the SLI, or perhaps making poor remarks as to how SWA does things. In those cases, I can see SWA guys looking negatively at those instances, especially since this isn't a simple "merger", as you put it. But overall, being cautiously optimistic that the SLI will go appropriately, I think you can expect a welcoming group. And I know you can expect a wonderful career working as a SWA pilot, because this job is absolutely incredible, from the schedule, to the benefits, to the pay, to (most of all) how this company takes care of its folks.