You guys should look in the mirror
instead of blaming mesa for everthing that is wrong with the world, maybe a collective we should all take a good hard look in the mirror. we as ALPA members dropped the ball a long time ago in regards to scope and where rj's should go. i know as much as air wiskey and comair guys like to talk about how they would like to retire at their respective companies, let's face it, wouldn't they all rather be flying at a major somewhere. ALPA national never thought a little 50 seat rj would ever be a threat to the big boys until it was too late. the answer was to try to protect mainline pilot's routes through scope language, a technique which we have all witnessed doesn't do squat. in a perfect world, all of those rj's should've been flown by mainline pilots at mainline wages and benefits. turboprops should have stayed at the commuters. we would have never even had the term "regional airline" in the first place. what ALPA's scope language did is allowed the commuters to grow into regional airlines at the expense of mainline jobs. had we all insisted that those aircraft go to the majors, that would have meant more jobs for all of us, with more benefits, and a higher quality of life. it wasn't mesa that did this...it was all of us that created this monster. unfortunately mesa saw a new devil arise in the form of JO. he thinks about ways around the system faster than ALPA can stop him. mesa guys saw their jets going elsewhere...(didn't you guys at piedmont used to have dc-9's???) it would've been nice if the mesa guys could've counted on ALPA for support...but why should they. ALPA is the reason this all got started in the first place. i believe that ALPA has its place...at the majors, where it can use its resources to try and protect the compensation and quality of life issues that those before us have worked so hard to capture. but at a regional??? come on...let's be real, ALPA isn't concerned about you. where does the money come from??? mesa? piedmont? allegheny? regional carriers should form a union who has their interests at heart, not the mainline carrier. your 1.95% does nothing to secure your job. remember delta signed an industry leading contract while the comair guys were on strike.
ask any mesa pilot if he or she wouldn't gladly trade in his id for that of any mainline carrier. ask yourself the same question. if we would've all refused to negotiate pay rates for rj's long ago they would've never been brought on the property and many more of us would be in the greener pastures on the other side. mesa was only trying to protect their flying since the rest of us in ALPA screwed things up for everyone years ago. mesa bashing isn't the answer. finding common ground amongst all of the regional carriers is.