PCL - I was in the middle of all of that and what you wrote about date of hire is absolutely not the truth.
In fact, Dan Ford is who I'm quoting when I write the generalization "By paycheck, or equipment type, a merger would have been a staple" My joke at the time was asking to print up "I'd be grateful for a staple" stickers.
I'm not trying to pick a fight with you, but you deliberately mischaracterizing what happened in 1999 & 2000 is a disservice to pretty much everyone involved, including our current ALPA leadership who introduced the PID to the floor.
From a "unionist" perspective, unity is a good thing and the PID was the right thing to do. It would be better if it had been successful, but just because it failed does not mean it was wrong.