Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

Medical Exam Question

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web

GateGirl

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 12, 2003
Posts
93
After high school I decided I wanted to join the military. It took me almost 2 years to get into the US Navy (it took me about 8 months before they would give me a date to start basic training, then I had to wait about a year for that ship date) After the worst 3 months of my life (I broke my foot, and I aquired whooping cough) A week after my divisions graduation I passed out in church and I was rushed to the hospital. The doctor there decided I had Asthma and sent me in for medical testing the following day. I took the fun medical tests and then a non-military medical student came in and asked me really intellegent questions like "when you run do you get out of breath" or "when you are going through ITE (aka getting your butt beaten by your RDC) do you have trouble breathing. and she decided I had mild persistent asthma. A military doctor came in and told me based on my "test results" I was getting discharged because I had mild persistent asthma. I was given a bunch of medication and sent on my way. When I was returning back to my division I looked at my medical records and it said on the print-out from the computer that my test were negative for asthma. Someone had crossed that out and written on there that I had mild persistent asthma.

Fast Forward about 7 months. After I returned from the Navy I went back to my place of work which was Colgan Air where I work as an ops/gate/ramp agent. I got accepted to Embry-Riddle so I could pay to much money for my flight training all while obtaining my college degree (I dont have one becuase I joined the Navy as opposed to going to college) Well I go in for my first class medical and I fill out the fun little questionare which asks if I have a history of asthma. Well yea, I got discharged from the Navy for it (by the way I never had asthma before or after that one incident) a few more questions and it asks if I have ever been medically discharged from the military. Well duh. So those are the only two things I have to mark yes to. Other than that Im in pretty good health. Before the lovely doctor even sees me he goes your disqualified. I almost dropped dead right there. He said asthma was disqualifying. I was like I had one asthma attack that I dont even think was an asthma attack, and your telling me that not only to I not get to be in the military something I had dreamed about my whole entire life, but I cant be a pilot. Excuse me I think I have a prop to run into. He does the medical exam and he takes extensive notes on my single asthma attack. The doctor told me to send my medical records in to him and he would forward them on to the FAA. I thought that somewhere amongst all the discharge papers the Navy so kindly gave me would be my medical records. But it wasnt. I called him today and he said he was going to send my test in as deferred and that i could send the copy of my medical records to him and he would forward them to the FAA or I could send my medical records directly to the FAA for review.

Now as you can see Im stuck between a rock and a hard place. I just wrote a lovely check for 15,000 to Riddle where I am supposed to start in January. And if I cant get my first class well than what the heck is the point. So I am open for suggestions. Should I just go and see another doctor?? Can I do that so soon?? Anyway, anything you have that would help would be amazing. Thanks!!
 
I cant claim to be qualified to speak about medical matters, and I dont think many others on here are. My advice would be to join AOPA (if you havent already) and take advantage of their Aeromedical advice.

Good Luck!
 
Thanks for the advice. I checked the FAA'a webpage and I dont see any mention of asthma being disqualifing. Im hoping this just turns out to be that the medical examiner i used is helf retarded....
 
Get a second opinion!

GateGirl, I have been asthmatic since I was five years old and I am now 35. I hold a first class medical and have no problems passing the first class medical as well. Each time I go in to get my medical renewed, I have to submit a letter from my doctor stating that my asthma is controlled and will not effect my abilities in flying or safely operating an aircraft. After 6 months or so, I get a letter from OKC that states that my first class medical has been approved. I cannot speak for the discharge part, but based on my asthmatic history, I have no problems. I hope this helps.
 
First, you might want to find a new AME but your current AME may be improperly interpreting Section 67.105: Ear, nose, throat, and equilibrium.

Ear, nose, throat, and equilibrium standards for a first-class airman medical certificate are:

b) No disease or condition of the middle or internal ear, nose, oral cavity, pharynx, or larynx that --

(1) Interferes with, or is aggravated by, flying or may reasonably be expected to do so; or

(2) Interferes with, or may reasonably be expected to interfere with, clear and effective speech communication.

(c) No disease or condition manifested by, or that may reasonably be expected to be manifested by, vertigo or a disturbance of equilibrium.


The advice about AOPA is good - for $39 dollars a year, you will then have access to AOPA medical advisers who can help resolve problems like this. As far as the FAA and your militay medical records - I suggest that you do not give them permission (they may ask you to sign a form that grants them such authority) to look at them as the aeromedical branch can use such records to establish that you have a "history" of such and such ailment in order to form the basis for a disqualification.

I took the fun medical tests and then a non-military medical student came in and asked me really intellegent questions like "when you run do you get out of breath" or "when you are going through ITE (aka getting your butt beaten by your RDC) do you have trouble breathing.

What ever happened to getting a second oponion? Even in the military you should have been able to request a second opinion/ set of tests to confirm that kind of diagnosis! I am not a doctor (but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last week) but it sounds to me like you simply had some form of respitory infections - Bronchitis or possibly mild Pneumonia - and neither the med student or the doctor did a proper follow up and you were misdiagnosed! You know I bet that if you really want to do your stint in the military, although it may require jumping through more than a few hoops - if you can get a clean bill of health from an asthma specialist, you may then be able to go through the VA (US Senator would be go also) and get this reviewed and possibly even reversed.


Michael
 
It may be a pain in the butt, but I think you should get another asthma test from a regular doctor. Then, pending those results, go to a different AME. Its your right to get second opinions.
 
thanks you guys are awesome!!
 

Latest posts

Latest resources

Back
Top