Provide an update when AA and SW are in ALPA.
The important thing is they have a union. But it really boils down to the individual pilot group and what they do with their resources, whether they are SWAPA, APA, or ALPA.
The anti ALPA folks are often pilots who feel disappointed about their career for whatever reason, and want to blame ALPA. The reality is ALPA can't save anyone from crappy management decisions, nor can they prevent an individual pilot group from self-destructing. ALPA is not perfect but it is the best resource available and have certainly contributed more to the profession than any independent union has.