Dave Benjamin said:
What could ALPA have done to prevent SkyWest and GoJets from underbidding Air Wisconsin?
Did ALPA tell Air Wisconsin management how much to bid?
Did ALPA advise Air Wisconsin management to not buy 70 seaters?
Do you really think losing flying is anything new to UAL pilots? If they're losing flying do you think they care whether it's a union or non-union pilot keeping them on the street? Do you think they were happy to see Air Wisconsin get former mainline flying but sad when "non-union" SkyWest got the knod?
Tell me what you think the role of a union is?
Is the union designed to protect pilots from poor managment decisions? Is the union supposed to magically control the marketplace?
If SkyWest pilots were represented by ALPA would you be perfectly content to see the flying go to SkyWest?
Good post. I actually think that some UAL pilots prefer new UAX flying go to those carriers (whether they're union or not) who will provide jets for jobs, and we all know that AWAC isn't one who is willing to do that, based on our history with big blue.
This is a big leap for me but here goes: United controls the UAX show, and it's their right to do so. They had been losing tons of $$ for years, due to their own mismanagement. While big blue was losing it before BK, AWAC, SkyWest, and ACA were raking it in with excellent profitability. United thinks 'why are we losing money and they're doing excellent?' That's not fair, let's renegotiate and get lower costs for our UAX carriers, and that will help get us out of BK and keep the court happy'.
Their mismanagement of their own nest is besides the point, and so is "lower cost = lower quality". If they really cared about quality they would've redone the ORD concourse in ORD when they had the chance, like AMR did for Eagle.
Meanwhile, even today, CASM of RJ's is still higher than that at the majors. And I've recently heard stories of Mesup's JO asking United for rate increases, that they're losing money doing the UAX business. 'Welcome to our world, big blue says'.
My company's management played poker, bluffed, and lost to others, plain and simple. But they made some cash in the process (at least $90 Mil + $125 Mil presumably). Good for them I guess, but we want our back pay, and they've got it, it was never passed on to United. That is a whole other story which I'm sure you'll hear about.
I love the modern American free market airline economy. Anyone have a valium?