hyper said:OK avbug. You sound agitated, but my intent wasn't to dispute your post and I don't think it reflects that. I simply wanted to share an opinion of the FAA that I happened to have due to a discussion about this years ago.
"......... but the pilot may be called into question on how he obtained the necessary visual references if the ceiling was below DH/DA/MDA."
Exactly my point. So while VIS is controlling (we all agree on that) the ceiling needs to be considered in the event that our friend is on the ramp in the muck and wants an explanation about your landing in VV001.
Actually I've gone into JAX with VV001 and RVR1800 on many occasion. Approach is still legal.
Isn't that exactly what I said?