Hi Mogus! It's great to hear that you have a goal such as the USAFA in mind. I very recently receieved my Letter of assurance to the academy, so hopefully I will be able to help you out.
1) First of all, having a PPl will definitely look good. I really don't know how strongly the admissions panel will weigh it, but it definitely can't hurt. I too am working on my PPL. If anything, getting your license early will most likely help you excel in airmanship classes at the academy, and perhaps will afford you the opportunity to be a IP or be on the "flying team." But in short, yes the license can't hurt you. As a matter of fact, it even asks on the application if you do have a pilot's license. Also, having it will show your interest in aviation, and from what I hear right now, the Air Force needs pilots.
2) You have a good ACT score, but definitely take it again. Even if you get it to a score you are satisfied with, still take it. I had to take like 10 different tests (6 SATs, and 4 ACTs), although I did much better on the SAT. The standardized tests are one of the most heavily weighted components of your application (so I hear), but they do definitely look at the "whole person." Just to let you know, I was accepted with just a little above average SAT score.
3) Hmmm, I really don't know what a 3.65 equates to. Here in Texas we use the 100 point scale, so I can't really tell you much. ( I was accepted with a 96.5 GPA if that helps). Very very important though, make sure that you are taking the hardest possible curriculum offered at your school. Make sure that you are taking all AP/ honors classes. From what I hear, this is the component the board weighs most. Also, try to keep your class rank in the top 10%.
4) First of all, get involved! Hate to break it to ya, but on the application, they only ask for the activities that you've done from the 10th grade and up. Remember that 85% of the typical entering class has a varsity letter award, and I think 90+% has been involved in a varsity sport; definitely something to think about. In reference to your paintball and church activites, put them down on your application, everything helps.
5) Good job getting started early. Did you apply for summer seminar by any chance? But anyhow, it won't be a while till you get your "Candidate pack." Expect an "Instructions to Precandidates" in April. I didn't actually receive my "candidate pack" till October, so you still have a lot of time. Find out about nominations, remember you can't get in without a nomination. I would write to your sources (i.e. congressman, and senators) this summer. Practice for the PAE, remember, the scores count towards your appointment. Also, if you have not done so, get in touch with your admissions liason officer (ALO).
Also, just wanted to add 1 thing. Indeed the selection panel uses the "whole person" method of selecting candidates, but remember 1 thing. 60% of your "admissions score" comes from your academics (SAT/ACT, GPA, class rank, types of classes, etc.), 20% comes from extracurricular activities, and 20% comes from PAE, essays, and recommendation from your liason officer.
For right now, sit back and relax, and try to make yourself look as good as possible. Also, make sure you do something leadership oriented. You don't have to hold a class office to get in, just make sure you do some leadership oriented things. For example, I was involved in 5 different clubs, didn't hold officer positions, but was involved in many committees, and held many committee chairs.
Best of luck to you. If you have any questions E-mail me or IM me at "StreetbikerFZR." Good luck!
Leo Romero
El Paso, TX
"Man's flight through life is sustained by the power of his knowledge." - USAFA